Growing but Declining?

In the 1950s and 1960s, Churches of Christ were the fastest-growing religious organization in the United States. The churches flourished especially in southern and western states, including Oklahoma. In this compelling history, historian W. David Baird examines the key characteristics, individuals, and debates that have shaped the Churches of Christ in Oklahoma from the early nineteenth century to the beginning of the twenty-first century.

Beginning with an account of the Stone-Campbell movement, which emerged along the American frontier in the early 1800s, and continuing with how the members of this movement first came to Oklahoma, Baird highlights the role of two prominent missionaries during this period. He then describes the second generation of missionaries who came along during the era of the Twin Territories, prior to statehood.

In 1906, as a result of disagreements regarding faith and practice, followers of the Stone-Campbell Movement divided into two organizations: Churches of Christ and Disciples of Christ. Baird then focuses solely on Churches of Christ in Oklahoma, all the while keeping a broader national context in view. Drawing on extensive research, Baird delves into theological and political debates and explores the role of the Churches of Christ during the two world wars.

As Churches of Christ grew in number and size throughout the country during the mid-twentieth century, controversy loomed. Oklahoma’s “Churches of Christ argued over everything from Sunday schools and the support of orphan’s homes to worship elements, gender roles in the church, and biblical interpretation” (xii). And nobody could agree on why church membership began to decline in the 1970s, despite exciting new community outreach efforts.

This history by an accomplished scholar provides a solid background and new insight into the question of whether Churches of Christ locally and nationally will be able to reverse course and rebuild their membership in the twenty-first century.

A Mix of the Good, Bad, and Ugly

I did not grow up Church of Christ (pause for the gasps to die down). I actually grew up Methodist, went to a Baptist school for undergrad, and then ACU, a Church of Christ school for graduate. The Church of Christ tradition is certainly not in my blood or bones.

Yet, the stories that come out of the Church of Christ tradition are important and valuable. Through satire and humor, Perry C. Cotham colorfully brings to life these practical insights about church life in general and pulpit ministry specifically. He presents a unique view of authentic Christian men and women and the joys, pains, and serendipities they experience along their faith journey.

Cotham’s purpose for this book is twofold: One, to invite people to smile, at times even to laugh, but always reflect on some of their own personal memories of their early church life; Two, to play a small role in preserving a valuable part of one church’s heritage. While some will have the mindset that the church is not for laughter or merriment, Cotham wants us to rethink how we view church and how we view those early disciples and Jesus. Can we really imagine anyone going to a wedding reception and not enjoying the moment with laughter and smiles? Overall, Cotham offers a collection of humorous, irreverent, and sometimes sad stories and observations from his long career within one unique Christian tradition, bringing about a new commandment: “Thou shalt not take thyself seriously” (19).