Category: Preaching

  • What Does It Mean to Preach?

    One Word Changes Everything

    There is a word that sits at the heart of what preaching is, and most preachers have never heard it.

    The word is attestation.

    It sounds technical. It is. But what it names is something every preacher has felt in the pulpit — and something every congregation has experienced in the pew, even if they could not name it. So let me define it carefully, and then let it go, and see if the reality it describes does not feel immediately familiar.


    The Definition

    To attest is to bear witness. Not to report, not to explain, not to argue — to witness. The difference matters enormously.

    When a reporter describes an event, she was not necessarily there. When a lawyer argues a case, he is constructing a position. When a teacher explains a concept, she is transmitting information. But when a witness testifies, she is saying something irreducibly personal: I was there. I saw it. I am staking my credibility — and in some cases my life — on what I tell you.

    That is attestation. And that, I want to suggest, is preaching.

    In my forthcoming book Preaching in the Present Tense: Scripting Transformative Sermons, I define preaching as attestation — the embodied witness of a formed person to a living Word addressed to a particular community in the present tense. The preacher is not a reporter delivering news from a distant country. The preacher is a witness who has been in the text, been read by the text, and now stands before the congregation to say: I have seen it. And I am staking my life on what I found there.


    Three Biblical Examples

    The concept is not mine. It runs through the New Testament like a thread.

    At Pentecost, Peter stands before the crowd in Jerusalem and does not simply describe what happened to Jesus. He confirms it, vouches for it, declares it from his own experience and from the testimony of the prophets: “This Jesus God raised up, and of that all of us are witnesses” (Acts 2:32). The crowd is cut to the heart. They cry out: “What should we do?” Something has happened that a lecture could not produce. A witness has spoken, and the Word has become present address.

    At the well in Samaria, the woman leaves her water jar — that small, telling detail — and runs back to the village. She does not deliver a theological treatise. She says: “Come and see a man who told me everything I have ever done” (John 4:29). That is attestation in its most elemental form. She saw something. She is telling you. Her life is the evidence.

    At Horeb, Elijah stands in the cave, exhausted and afraid, and delivers a careful account of his own faithfulness and the people’s failure. The angel does not dispute his facts. But the question that comes back is not about the facts: “What are you doing here, Elijah?” (1 Kings 19:9). The question reads him more truthfully than his answer reads himself. Attestation is not only what the preacher says to the congregation. It is what the text says to the preacher, before the preacher says anything to anyone.


    What Attestation Sounds Like

    Here is a simple list of what attestation feels like when it becomes speech. These are not synonyms for a technical term. They are the human voices behind it:

    I attest. I confirm. I bear witness. I vouch for this. I was there. I have seen it. I stake my life on it. I say this with my whole self.

    Every time a preacher steps into the pulpit, one of these sentences — spoken or unspoken — is the ground on which everything else stands. The sermon that lacks this ground is information. The sermon that stands on this ground is proclamation.


    Why the Word Matters

    Paul Ricoeur, the French philosopher whose work on testimony and witness runs beneath much of what I am saying here, describes attestation as a mode of assurance that joins belief and moral integrity — a confidence in the self that is capable of acting and being held responsible. It is not certainty. It is commitment. The witness does not say I can prove this beyond all doubt. The witness says I have seen it, and I will not unsay it, whatever the cost.

    That is the difference between a preacher who explains the resurrection and a preacher who attests it. Both may use the same words. But only one of them is standing on the ground of personal witness. And the congregation can tell the difference.

    The technical word for all of this is attestation. The everyday words are: testify, confirm, declare, vouch for, bear witness, stand behind, stake your life on.

    Use any of them. They all point to the same thing.

    The preacher who has been in the text, been claimed by the text, and now speaks from within that encounter — that preacher is attesting. And when that happens, something occurs in the room that could not have been planned.


    A Final Word

    Near the end of my book’s theology of preaching, after surveying what the traditions have said about preaching across two millennia, I arrive at this:

    Preaching is neither pure divine address nor merely human construction or correlation. It is partnership — a genuinely participatory event in which God’s living initiative and human response together become more than either alone.

    Attestation is the human side of that partnership. Not the human side replacing the divine side. Not the human side explaining the divine side. The human side bearing witness to the divine side — in words, in presence, in the life behind the words — so that the congregation hears not only what the text once said but what it is saying now, to them, in this moment.

    That is what preaching is. That is attestation.

    And when I get into the pulpit, I stake my life on it.


    Tim Sensing is Scholar in Residence at the Graduate School of Theology at Abilene Christian University. This post draws on his forthcoming book Preaching in the Present Tense: Scripting Transformative Sermons (Cascade Books, 2027). More sermons, articles, and resources are available at HomileticalSensings.

  • Preaching as Sacramental Encounter: Hearing, Seeing, and Encountering Christ

    From its earliest centuries, the Church has understood itself to be constituted by both the proclamation of the Word and the celebration of the sacraments. Augustine captured this balance, insisting that when the Word is preached,

    “it is Christ himself who speaks,”

    while also distinguishing between the verbum audibile (the Word heard in preaching) and the verbum visibile (the Word seen in the sacraments). In his homilies, Augustine would remind congregations that they “see” the Word in the water, bread, and wine, while also “hearing” the Word in proclamation and reading. Both forms of the Word mediate Christ’s presence, though by different modes. This early distinction laid the foundation for all subsequent Christian reflection on how the Word and sacraments relate in the economy of grace.

    Practical Tip: When preaching, remember that your words and liturgical actions work alongside the sacraments. Preaching and sacrament are two channels of Christ’s presence, each reinforcing the other.


    Augustine and the Purpose of Preaching

    Tom Long, in Senses of Preaching, describes a common scenario: a preacher shaking hands with congregants after the Sunday sermon. What do you hope they will say? Long draws on Augustine’s guidance in On Christian Doctrine:

    “To teach is a necessity, to please is a sweetness, to persuade is a victory.”

    Augustine would be pleased to hear, “That was a nice sermon” (delight), happier to hear, “That was a nice sermon. I learned something today” (delight and teach), and most satisfied with, “That was a nice sermon. I learned something today. I am going to do something about it” (delight, teach, and persuade).

    Practical Tip: Craft sermons that delight, teach, and persuade. Always ask: How will this message shape the listener’s week and actions?


    Orthodox Theology: Preaching as Icon in Time

    Eastern Orthodox theology approaches preaching through the lens of the iconographic economy, wherein both spoken word and visual icon participate in the same sacramental logic of revelation. John of Damascus explains that just as icons make the invisible visible, preaching makes the eternal Word audible in time. The Orthodox understanding of theoria (contemplative vision) encompasses both seeing and hearing as modes of encountering divine reality.

    Alexander Schmemann emphasizes that the homily participates in the “sacramental transformation” of the Divine Liturgy, moving worshippers from this world to the Kingdom. John Zizioulas stresses that preaching, like icons, mediates Christ’s eschatological presence through the work of the Spirit.

    Practical Tip: Treat the sermon as part of the liturgical movement. Every word participates in the worshipping community’s encounter with Christ.


    Roman Catholic Perspectives: Homily as Quasi-Sacramental

    Karl Rahner characterizes preaching as quasi-sacramental, observing that the Word of God proclaimed in the Church mediates grace in a manner analogous to the sacraments: it is a human action through which God is present and active, while retaining a qualitative distinction from the dominical sacraments.

    Vatican II’s Sacrosanctum Concilium affirms:

    “Christ is present in His word, since it is He Himself who speaks when the holy scriptures are read in the Church.”

    The Catechism emphasizes that the liturgy of the Word and the liturgy of the Eucharist together form one single act of worship.

    Practical Tip: Connect your sermon to Eucharistic preparation and participation. Show how the Word heard opens hearts to the sacramental presence of Christ.


    Lutheran and Reformed Perspectives: Preaching as Means of Grace

    The Lutheran tradition, following the Augsburg Confession, affirms that

    “through the Word and the Sacraments… the Holy Spirit is given, who works faith.”

    For Luther, the preached Word is the viva vox evangelii, the living voice of the gospel that accomplishes what it promises. Calvin likewise describes preaching as the “external means” by which God draws people into faith, calling it a “kind of sacrament.” Preaching and sacraments are mutually interpretive: the Word explains what the sacraments signify, while the sacraments confirm the Word.

    Practical Tip: Preach with the understanding that your words are divine instruments, participating in God’s work of faith and transformation.


    Barthian Theology: The Word Made Present

    Karl Barth asserts that true Christian preaching is a theological and spiritual act in which Jesus Christ is both the content of the sermon and the “real presence” of the speech act. Scripture witnesses to the Word, and preaching becomes the event in which the Word is proclaimed anew.

    “In preaching, the Word of God comes to the congregation, not merely as human speech but as the divine address.”

    Practical Tip: Preach with expectation of encounter. Christ may speak through your words—prepare yourself spiritually and exegetically.


    Anglican Insights: Formation and Transformation

    The Anglican tradition emphasizes the inseparability of Word and Sacrament. The Thirty-Nine Articles affirm that the Church is “the assembly in which the pure Word of God is preached, and the Sacraments be duly ministered.” Julia Gatta notes:

    “Through the eucharistic liturgy we are always being formed and reformed into the body of Christ… Preaching tries to do just that.”

    Practical Tip: Use the sermon to connect Scripture to communal formation, guiding the congregation toward both understanding and practice in the context of liturgy.


    Modern Theological Perspectives: Preaching as Symbolic Mediation

    Contemporary voices highlight preaching as symbolic, participatory, and transformative. Ruthanna B. Hooke observes:

    “Preaching is a sacramental event of communion with the triune God … Preaching draws participants into Christ’s dying and rising, and hence into a mode of power known in vulnerability.”

    Similarly, Robert Smith Jr. notes that in African-American homiletics, preaching is an exegetical escort into God’s presence, experienced as liberating and transformative. Cleophus LaRue emphasizes the hermeneutic power of preaching grounded in lived experience, while Victor Anderson highlights African preaching as inherently liturgical and encounter-oriented.

    Practical Tip: Consider preaching as participatory and embodied. Invite congregants into active engagement, not passive listening—letting them experience God’s presence in the act of worship itself.


    Conclusion: Preaching as Sacramental Encounter

    Across Orthodox, Catholic, Lutheran, Reformed, Anglican, and contemporary traditions, preaching is consistently recognized as a conduit for Christ’s presence. Terminology differs—sacramental, quasi-sacramental, sacrament-like—but the conviction is universal:

    • Preaching is not mere instruction; it is an encounter with the living Word.

    • Preaching integrates with Word and sacrament, liturgy and life.

    • Preaching mediates transformation, formation, and encounter with Christ.

    Final Practical Tip: Prepare sermons as spaces of encounter—delighting, teaching, and persuading—where the congregation experiences the living Christ, shaped by Spirit and Word. Preaching is sacramental in efficacy, attesting to the presence of Christ and forming the Church into His likeness.

  • Preaching

    I love preaching. I preached my first sermon when I was 13. The congregation let me preach any Sunday night I wanted, as long as our preacher read every sermon before I preached it. A deacon used to drive me to nearby towns so I could preach.  Others in the congregation affirmed and encouraged me. And because of my home church, I heard my calling. My home church birthed and fostered my love of preaching.
         I admire good preaching. I spend more time thinking about preaching than any other subject. And I am thankful that ACU gives me the opportunity to teach preachers how to preach, to be able to help students grow in their professional and personal identity formation.
         While I teach in a school, preaching cannot remain in a laboratory. Preaching is not a “solo performance” or a “spectator sport.” Preaching is a communal activity. One voice cannot be the only voice that reverberates for the whole community. Preaching involves listening to the many voices that make up the Body of Christ. Listening does not lead to fragmentation or a discordant cacophony, but through communal discernment, pastoral care, and context awareness, preaching becomes a living witness to God’s activities among the congregation. In dialogue with Scripture, Church, and Community, a new and living word is possible. Otherwise, preaching is mere talk about the same old things in the same old ways.
         And preachers develop different styles and voices. My primary objective is not to force preachers to preach like me but to find their own homiletical voice. Even I do not preach with the same style to a congregation of 2000 as I do to a congregation of 20. A Metroplex preacher will sound different from someone from the East Coast. Someone with a teaching voice may exemplify one way of doing the task, while someone else uses a testimonial voice. Preachers come in all different shapes and sizes. And the church needs them all. While I might compare and contrast those styles so that my perspective is clarified, I’m not seeking to dilute or deform anyone’s gift or cast suspicion on another’s faith. My primary gift to teaching preaching is my ability to hear the what and how of the homiletical moment. I might even critique a famous preacher like Craddock or Willimon, but only for the pedagogical objective of letting the student’s own homiletical wings take flight. I might, through hyperbole, swing the pendulum one way, but only so the student can intentionally choose the arc their own style will swing.
         So, how do people learn to preach? The short answer is: “They just do.” However, people do not “just do it.” They have to “figure it out” to “get the feel” of preaching for themselves. William Willimon compares the teaching of preaching to the teaching of woodcarving and the making of biscuits.
         So there’s a sense of which I still don’t know a lot about teaching preaching. I mean, I realize that seeds are planted, were planted in me, which didn’t bear fruit until years later. I realize that it’s more like learning how to carve wood than it is a technique of first you do this, second you do that. You’ve got to get the feel of it. You have to – it’s more like learning to make biscuits than it is how to write an essay on something.
         Learning “how-to” is more easily and safely negotiated if it is not undertaken alone. Let’s take biscuits, for example. Studying a cookbook or watching an infomercial does not miraculously produce master chefs. Total recall of principles and propositions that follow the recipe line-by-line will not necessarily produce melt-in-your-mouth biscuits. Somehow, the “knack” is missing. But when Grandma stands over your shoulder, another experience altogether occurs.
         Good preaching pays attention to the rubrics governing exegesis, interpretation, and communication. But knowledge of exegesis, hermeneutics, and rhetoric do not themselves produce good preaching. Some unschooled people (like the apostles) seem to “know in their bones” what preaching involves, while some educated people seem never to learn and are a pain to endure.
         As students mature in Christ, they become authentic persons with passion, conviction, and character. This is not done overnight nor through a set of classes arranged in the curriculum. It begins with the parents in the home and in collaboration with the Christian community, the church. Students develop spiritual disciplines that mold them into people of character. And throughout the process, models and mentors play a vital function. In this sense, the church gives birth to preachers. The teacher functions merely as a midwife for what the church has conceived. And the student preacher will be given back to the church for service and continued growth.
         Preacher education does not stop with a diploma. Continuing education, exploration, innovation within a changing culture, and continued growth in actual experience in the life of the church need to be cultivated. Older ministers will function as mentors, wise elders will shepherd, and gracious congregants will patiently draw forth the best. The life-long journey of becoming a preacher is always an unfinished work that requires continued construction.
         I love preaching because I love preachers and I love the church.
  • FAQs about Homiletics

    Below are some FAQs from my homiletics textbook, now forthcoming as Preaching in the Present Tense: Scripting Transformative Sermons (Eugene, OR: Cascade, forthcoming).

    1. What is the central aim of preaching?

    The central aim of preaching is to facilitate an encounter between God, the biblical text, and the community. Preaching should make concrete theological claims about God, bearing witness to the congregation in order to transform them into the image of Jesus. It’s about more than just conveying information; it’s about God acting through the sermon to shape and reshape the community of faith. The sermon also acts as a performative and referential speech act, affecting the hearer and spurring them to decision.

    2. What does it mean to preach “intentionally” and “in the present tense”?

    Preaching intentionally means that the preacher must discern a purpose for an individual sermon, as every text of Scripture contains more than one sermon, but a preacher should only preach one sermon each Sunday, focusing on one thing well. Preaching in the present tense means addressing the current concerns of individuals, the congregation, and the wider community, finding the correspondence between the “concerns of the text” and the “concerns of the people.” It involves interpreting “what the text meant” to reveal “what the text means,” moving from the world described by the Bible to the world it imagines.

    3. How does Sensing suggest a sermon should be designed or “scripted”?

    The text emphasizes that sermons should be “formed from end to beginning,” meaning the preacher should first identify the desired outcome or purpose before developing the sermon’s content. Scripting should respect the literary genre and rhetorical form of the text, allowing the text’s form to inspire the sermon’s design rather than imposing a predetermined structure. The sermon’s plot should have a single point of entry and maintain a consistent point of view.

    4. What role does theology play in the process of preaching?

    Theology is foundational to preaching. Theology is described as a big enough word that it carries the weight of “love” and “gospel”, encompassing various sub-disciplines like Christology, Pneumatology, Ecclesiology, and Eschatology. It provides the “what” of preaching, the substance of the message. The preacher’s own theological commitments and presuppositions significantly influence their interpretation of Scripture and, consequently, the content and delivery of their sermons.

    5. How does the concept of “witness” relate to preaching?

    Preaching is presented as an act of witness. Scripture is a witness to God’s ongoing story throughout history. The preacher, as a witness, beholds, sees, experiences, observes, and perceives the biblical text, encountering God through it. Then, the preacher attests, gives out, says, makes others aware, and testifies to the community. Therefore, God, by means of the witness of the biblical text and the witness of the preacher, encounters the congregation. This witness isn’t simply about relaying information; it’s about sharing a lived encounter with God. The preacher declares what they behold, inviting the congregation to share in that experience.

    6. What is meant by the “fusion of horizons” and how does it apply to preaching?

    The “fusion of horizons,” drawing on Gadamer’s hermeneutics, describes the merging of the preacher’s horizon with the horizon of the biblical text. An ellipse has two foci: when two circles are brought into relationship, their centers become the two foci of a new figure. Yet the theological model Sensing proposes is “(at a minimum) triadic,” with three foci representing “the three dimensions of the hermeneutical encounter.” The fusion of horizons “is thus not merely a human achievement and can become a pneumatological event in which the Spirit enables, judges, and transforms the interpreter’s understanding.” “Fusion” is but one metaphor used by Sensing to describe the hermeneutical process.

    7. What are some practical tools Sensing offers for sermon preparation?

    The text offers a storyboarding template to help organize sermon ideas, focusing on the title, focus, and function of the sermon. It also highlights the importance of plotlines (sequence or arrangement), indicating if the sermon is in the mode of immediacy or the mode of reflection, helping to follow the flow or movement of the episodes of the sermon from the beginning to the ending. The text also introduces the Core Affirmation, “a single, declarative sentence that names a central movement of God’s life with the world,” which fuses the focus statement and the function statement. Additionally, the text suggests using a modified form of Buttrick’s Moves and Structures as a flexible way to teach sermon design that respects textual form.

  • Experiments with AI

    Update: The book discussed here is now forthcoming as Preaching in the Present Tense: Scripting Transformative Sermons (Eugene, OR: Cascade, forthcoming). The draft and the AI-generated podcast have been removed while the book is in production.

    Recently I have experimented with AI. I attached my draft of Homiletics: A Very Short Introduction 2025. The AI generated an introduction, a brief outline, and a set of FAQs for me. Also, AI generated a podcast using my book as the content.

    Was it perfect? No. Here are a few examples. The podcast misses how I use the metaphor of window for example. It uses a multi-colored stained glass window, an image I do not use. I am using windows in a room that you see through. Different windows give you different perspectives of the same room. And, it uses the butterfly as an example of my definition of concretization when the butterfly is my example of missing the point of concretization. Later, it will define concretization in a better way. Describing concretization twice is one example of redundancy that was poorly sequenced. The podcast uses a positive image of a bridge when I am critical of the metaphor of a bridge. The use of “episodic preaching” is a confusion of my critique of “episodic memory” in an appendix and my use of episodes as sequencing plots. Ironically, Aristotle says “episodics” are the worst in Poetics. The podcast also provided made-up examples and illustrations. As it is often said, the AI hallucinated. However, all in all, I was quite impressed.

    AI Generated Summary

    Homiletics: A Very Short Introduction Under Construction by Tim Sensing

    The text provides a comprehensive guide to homiletics, exploring the art and practice of preaching. It investigates the calling and formation of preachers, emphasizing the importance of mentorship and the church community. The text examines key concepts such as exegesis, hermeneutics, and homiletics, stressing the need for contextual interpretation of scripture. It also presents various models and methods for sermon preparation, including focus statements, function statements, and core affirmations. Furthermore, it discusses narrative preaching, sermon structure, and the use of metaphors and images to connect with the congregation and make the theological claims of the text relevant for today.

    Overall Theme: This document provides an introduction to homiletics, emphasizing preaching intentionally in the present tense, understanding the theological purpose of sermons, respecting the literary genre and rhetorical form of texts, and viewing Scripture as witness. It also touches upon reaching contemporary audiences in an episodic fashion.

    Key Ideas and Concepts:

    • Preaching Intentionally & in the Present Tense:
      • The core idea is that preaching should be relevant and address the contemporary context of the audience. Sensing emphasizes moving from “what the text meant” to “what the text means.”
      • “Sermons in the present tense address the concerns of individuals, congregations, and the larger community.” The goal is to find correspondence between the “concerns of the text and the concerns of the people.”
      • Interpreting in the present tense begins with God’s revelation of Self in the Bible and what it means to call the Bible Scripture.
    • Theological Purpose of the Sermon:
      • A central question is, “What is the ‘what’ of preaching?” Sensing answers this with “theology,” which is a broad term encompassing various theological disciplines (Christology, Pneumatology, Ecclesiology, etc.) and forms (beatitude, lament, parable, etc.).
      • Each sermon should have a single, clear theological claim and a specific purpose for the audience. “One of the marks of good preaching is that it seeks to say one thing well.”
      • The purpose of a sermon is also found in its final end, “friendship with God,” and it’s primary proximate end, “the awakening of faith.”
    • Sermon Design & Structure:
      • Sensing suggests that sermons are “formed from end to beginning,” emphasizing the importance of knowing the destination or purpose before starting to preach. “Sermons are not propelled by powerful beginnings but are evoked by significant ends.”
      • He moves away from rigid outlines, preferring to think of a sermon as “an audible movement in time,” like a play or a story.
      • The document introduces a storyboarding template to aid in sermon preparation, focusing on Focus and Function.
      • Plots should have a single point of entry and point of view to avoid confusing the audience.
    • Scripture as Witness & the Role of the Preacher:
      • The text views Scripture as a witness, the “ongoing story of God witnessed throughout history by the people of God.” The preacher, as a witness, encounters God through the biblical text and testifies to the community.
      • Echoing The Second Helvetic Confession, Sensing contends that “the preached word of God is the Word of God.”
      • “Because God has raised Jesus from the dead, we believe and therefore confess Jesus is Lord!” is cited as a “core affirmation.” The preacher has beautiful feet when “one who beholds the living word of God who is Christ and swivels in the chair of the study or rise from your knees of prayer to your field of service to proclaim what is seen and heard.”
    • The Importance of Context & Culture:
      • Culture shapes the listener, serving as webs of significance through convictions, values, assumptions, biases, and formative symbols. The preacher should be aware of the cultural elements that affect the interpretation of scripture.
      • Contextualized preaching requires “greater faithfulness to the gospel of Jesus Christ but also greater responsiveness to the unique issues, hopes, fears, and concerns of particular congregations in specific times and places.”
    • Metaphor & Language:
      • Language functions as both a performative and a referential speech act.
      • Metaphor is a powerful tool for communicating meaning, and transferring insights from one domain to another. It re-describes reality by interacting tenor and vehicle.
    • The Episodic Audience:
      • The document acknowledges a shift towards “episodic” thinking, where meta-narratives are less emphasized. This has implications for how sermons are structured and delivered. “Episodics have lost the capacity or the will to make meta-plots.”
      • Sensing notes that episodic thinking may be linked to the influence of media and a world that lives from scene to scene.
    • Theological Interpretation of Scripture:
      • Scripture should not be read as any other book, and the interpretation of Scripture has a different telos (purpose) in the church than in other communities. The end is friendship with God, and the building up of God’s people.
      • Good theological interpretation must be evangelical, edifying, and prophetic.
      • Text, context, and community are essential components of theological reading.

    Quotes:

    • “Sermons are formed from end to beginning.”
    • “One of the marks of good preaching is that it seeks to say one thing well.”
    • “What you believe about God alters how you act towards others.”
    • “Episodics have lost the capacity or the will to make meta-plots.”
    • “This is my starting-point: no meaning can be determined out of context, but no context permits saturation.”
    • “The preacher, as witness, beholds, sees, experiences, observes, basks in, becomes aware, and perceives the Bible, and through its witness encounters God!”
    • “The triune God has bestowed this telos upon the Bible in sanctifying it for the church’s sake. In fact, there is no one telos of Holy Scripture, for it has a rich plurality of ends. Its final end is friendship with God: eternal participation in the infinite communion of love that is the perfect life of Father, Son, and Spirit.”

    Implications:

    • This document provides a framework for creating sermons that are theologically sound, contextually relevant, and engaging for a contemporary audience.
    • It encourages preachers to be intentional about their purpose, to respect the text, and to consider the cultural and cognitive landscape of their listeners.
    • The emphasis on Scripture as witness and the preacher as a testifier calls for authenticity and a personal encounter with God.

    FAQs

    1. What is the central aim of preaching, according to this text?

    The central aim of preaching is to facilitate an encounter between God, the biblical text, and the community. Preaching should make concrete theological claims about God, bearing witness to the congregation in order to transform them into the image of Jesus. It’s about more than just conveying information; it’s about God acting through the sermon to shape and reshape the community of faith. The sermon also acts as a performative and referential speech act, affecting the hearer and spurring them to decision.

    1. What does it mean to preach “intentionally” and “in the present tense”?

    Preaching intentionally means that the preacher must discern a purpose for an individual sermon as every text of Scripture contains more than one sermon, but a preacher should only preach one sermon each Sunday, focusing on one thing well. Preaching in the present tense means addressing the current concerns of individuals, the congregation, and the wider community, finding the correspondence between the “concerns of the text” and the “concerns of the people.” It involves interpreting “what the text meant” to reveal “what the text means,” moving from the world described by the Bible to the world it imagines.

    1. How does the text suggest a sermon should be designed or “scripted”?

    The text emphasizes that sermons should be “formed from end to beginning,” meaning the preacher should first identify the desired outcome or purpose before developing the sermon’s content. Scripting should respect the literary genre and rhetorical form of the text, allowing the text’s form to inspire the sermon’s design rather than imposing a predetermined structure. The sermon’s plot should have a single point of entry and maintain a consistent point of view.

    1. What role does theology play in the process of preaching?

    Theology is foundational to preaching. Theology is described as a big enough word that it carries the weight of “love” and “gospel”, encompassing various sub-disciplines like Christology, Pneumatology, Ecclesiology, and Eschatology. It provides the “what” of preaching, the substance of the message. The preacher’s own theological commitments and presuppositions significantly influence their interpretation of Scripture and, consequently, the content and delivery of their sermons.

    1. How does the concept of “witness” relate to preaching?

    Preaching is presented as an act of witness. Scripture is a witness to God’s ongoing story throughout history. The preacher, as a witness, beholds, sees, experiences, observes, and perceives the biblical text, encountering God through it. Then, the preacher attests, gives out, says, makes others aware, and testifies to the community. Therefore, God, by means of the witness of the biblical text and the witness of the preacher, encounters the congregation. This witness isn’t simply about relaying information; it’s about sharing a lived encounter with God. The preacher declares what they behold, inviting the congregation to share in that experience.

    1. What is meant by the “fusion of horizons” and how does it apply to preaching?

    The “fusion of horizons,” drawing on Gadamer’s hermeneutics, describes the merging of the preacher’s understanding (their horizon) with the horizon of the biblical text. As the two circles merge, the two centers form an ellipse. The new center is the intersection of the major and minor axes. The ellipse is a new geometric shape. This fusion creates a new understanding, a new way of seeing and interpreting the text in light of the preacher’s context and experiences. It’s a dynamic process of interaction and interpretation that leads to a richer and more meaningful understanding.

    1. What are some practical tools the text offers for sermon preparation?

    The text offers a storyboarding template to help organize sermon ideas, focusing on the title, focus, and function of the sermon. It also highlights the importance of plotlines (sequence or arrangement), indicating if the sermon is in the mode of immediacy or the mode of reflection, helping to follow the flow or movement of the episodes of the sermon from the beginning to the ending.

     

  • Confessing Jesus Christ

    A Charge to the Graduates

    Graduate School of Theology Covenant Service

    “The word is near you, on your lips and in your heart” (that is, the word of faith that we proclaim); because if you confess with your lips that Jesus is Lord and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved. For one believes with the heart and so is justified, and one confesses with the mouth and so is saved. The scripture says, “No one who believes in him will be put to shame.” For there is no distinction between Jew and Greek; the same Lord is Lord of all and is generous to all who call on him. For, “Everyone who calls on the name of the Lord shall be saved. But how are they to call on one in whom they have not believed? And how are they to believe in one of whom they have never heard? And how are they to hear without someone to proclaim him? And how are they to proclaim him unless they are sent? As it is written, ‘How beautiful are the feet of those who bring good news!’ But not all have obeyed the good news; for Isaiah says, ‘Lord, who has believed our message?’ So faith comes from what is heard, and what is heard comes through the word of Christ.”

    Core Affirmation: Because God has raised Jesus from the dead, we believe and therefore confess Jesus is Lord!

     Plot Line: *Once I recall being asked to give expert testimony. *So, what is the role of a witness. *Yet sometimes expert testimony is not received or given. *Nevertheless, we are still called to the ministry of testimony. * Therefore, we are being sent with beautiful feet. Why? Because we behold Jesus raised from the dead. *And we profess our faith that Jesus is Lord.

    Episode One: Once I recall being asked to give expert testimony for the case of the Sailor’s Mystery Signature. Walt’s Last Will & Testament was being contested. One of the key points of the dispute was his signature. Why me? Why was I asked to give expert testimony on a man’s signature? Because I had witnessed the signing of one of the only legal documents accessible, the Cape May Courthouse Church of Christ incorporation papers. Walt was a retired maritime sailor and a founding corporate member of our church plant. So, I took the stand, and I pledged my oath. I reported that the signature on the incorporation papers belonged to Walt. And within thirty seconds, I was dismissed. That was my one and only time to give expert testimony in a court of law.

    Episode Two: So, what is the role of a witness? Mislov Volf in After Our Likeness, uses the language of confession to describe our Christian witness.[1] Confession as testimony is Declarative: Volf says, it announces what the community believes about Jesus. We confess the saving word of the gospel of Jesus, a word that is effective, convicting sinners of their sin, bringing them to repentance, and eliciting faith in Jesus as Lord because God raised Jesus from the dead.

    Also, confession as testimony is Performative: Volf says, it transforms cognitive assent into active commitment. It commits the life of the confessor to the life and values of the community.

    Therefore, confession as testimony is Public: Volf says, we confess together as a community, and we invite others into our community.  We behold, therefore, we declare to others.

    We “Behold” — You’re standing on the street corner. A yellow F-150 runs the red light and hits the black sedan. You are the witness because you beheld the event in question. Therefore you “Declare.” Whether it is simply giving your statement to the police or going to court to testify, you are giving your voice to the events in question. While some will discount testimony as mere perception, our whole legal system is based on the fact that testimony is not perception but the report itself. And then the jury, once convinced by the testimony, is persuaded to act on the testimony as evidence. The event affects the witness; the testimony affects the jury.

    What is the role of a witness: To behold and to declare.

    Episode Three: Yet sometimes expert testimony is not received or given. Paul stands before the jury frustrated, lamenting, about the unbelief (11:20,23), lamenting about the disobedience (10:16, 21), and lamenting about the misguided zeal (10:2–4) of many of his fellow Jews. More precisely, Paul is frustrated that his fellow Jews have not taken the witness stand to proclaim that in Christ God has included the Gentiles. And so Paul makes arguments about Jews who have heard the gospel of inclusion preached through the words of the Law and Prophets, and do not participate in the confession. If Jesus is the telos of the Law, then confession that Jesus is Lord follows. And Paul aches for his people because the “story of glory,” with respect to the inclusion of the Gentiles, has come to a screeching halt with Israel’s failure to sit in the witness stand.[2] Sometimes expert testimony is not received or given.

    Episode Four: Nevertheless, we are still called to the ministry of testimony. We were not witnesses of the actual events 2000 years ago. We rely on the faithful testimony of eyewitnesses. We deem them reliable and therefore we believe. We are not left alone with just the eyewitness accounts, but God’s Spirit testifies to our spirit the truth of these events. And from our belief in a resurrected Jesus, we have experiences with a living Christ. And from our experience of a living Christ, we then give testimony that “Jesus is Lord.” And the chain of witness continues.

    Like a hinge—We Behold>therefore<We Declare. You cannot declare what you do not behold. And if you behold, you have the opportunity, if not the responsibility, to declare “Jesus is Lord”. This is the salvation we profess. And it will take you a lifetime to work out.

    You are not graduating this day with a law degree, an accounting degree, a psychology degree, or any other degree you will see on that stage tonight, but you are graduating with a theology degree. Because God has raised Jesus from the dead, we believe and therefore confess Jesus is Lord! We give testimony and declare to the fact that Jesus makes a difference in me, makes a difference in my vocation, and makes a difference in my community of faith.

    Matthew Love has a recent take on the preaching of John Henry Newman’s preaching motto: Heart speaks to heart — God’s modus operandi for reaching humans with the gospel is to summon from one heart to another. “How are they to hear without someone to proclaim him?” (Rom 10:14) Paul asks. But preaching, as the Apostle declares elsewhere, involves more than declarations preached before others; it involves contemplation, study, and prayer. So, Paul’s preaching and praying is coterminous. His aim for these Christians is this: “the eyes of your heart enlightened” (Eph 1:18). Such preaching assumes an anthropology wherein listeners are not simply couched as “thinking things” who require filled heads; they are understood as requiring moved hearts. Such an anthropology displays an understanding of Phillips Brook’s famous dictum concerning preaching as “truth through personality,” or even Paul’s self-disclosing vulnerability: “So deeply do we care for you that we are determined to share with you not only the gospel of God but also our own selves, because you have become very dear to us” (1 Thess 2:8). Preaching is communion between persons— Heart speaks to heart.[3]

    So, you are here ready to receive your diploma with beautiful regalia. Some of you didn’t think twice about the clothes you are covering up with your gown. Others took special care to select your wardrobe, maybe even something new. But did any of you check your feet. Yes, some of you even bought new shoes. Consider your shoes, they protect and support beautiful feet.

    The line in the hymn we sang is about you. “Take my life, and let it be Consecrated, Lord to Thee; … Take my feet and let them be Swift and beautiful for Thee.” It is with this word “beautiful” that Dr. Lee has recently written that our affections are formed. He describes it as a “conversion” into a way of life for those of us vocationally called into theological practices.[4]

    All the saints of God are baptized. From the baptized, some are called vocationally in service to God’s people. And those called have beautiful feet. You know you have beautiful feet if you are one who beholds the living word of God who is Christ and swivels in the chair of the study or rise from your knees of prayer to your field of service to proclaim what is seen and heard. The person who receives your ministry and beholds the transforming power of God in their hearts likewise turns to life, family, work, and community to live out their faith.

    Episode Five: Therefore, we are being sent with beautiful feet. Near us and even in us is the transforming word of salvation. We are changed, forgiven, renewed, and enriched. That in a nutshell is a theology of proclamation as testimony — the witness or preaching, the witness of serving, the witness of ministry. We are called to the ministry of beautiful feet. Because we behold Jesus raised from the dead … (Refrain)

      • We behold Jesus … Who met a woman at a well treating her as a person of dignity.
      • We behold Jesus … Who met a blind beggar and gave him relief.
      • We behold Jesus … Who met 5000 hungry folk and gave them bread and fish.
      • We behold Jesus … Who ministered to a rich guy in a sycamore tree of all places and brought salvation to his house.
      • We behold Jesus … Who restored life to the brother of two grieving sisters.
      • And we behold the countless stories, one right after another, of Jesus encountering people in their darkest hour, encountering people in their pain, facing people in their suffering, confronting people in their sin.
      • We behold Jesus … raised from the dead, ascended to the right hand of God, reigning today with all powers and authorities under his footstool.
      • And we behold that salvation is good news. And all these stories still testify today.

    Therefore, we are being sent with beautiful feet.

    Denouement or Episode Six: We behold that Jesus is raised from the dead; therefore, we profess our faith that Jesus is Lord. What we believe about Jesus as Lord defines our reality, our story, and our futures. Therefore, we profess our faith in community (songs, creeds, scriptures, baptisms, Lord’s Supper, hospital rooms, prison cells, and wherever your calling takes you) and we express our faith when we leave these halls of the academy as far as our beautiful feet will take us, even to the uttermost parts of the world.

     I believe Jesus is raised from the dead.

    Therefore, I confess that Jesus is Lord.

    In the name of the Creator, Redeemer, and Sustainer, Amen.

    [1] Miroslav Volf, After Our Likeness: The Church as the Image of the Trinity (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1998), 148.

    [2] A synthetic read of a more traditional reading of Romans and a reread represented by Michael Gorman, Becoming the Gospel, 286 and Stanley Stowers, A Rereading of Romans, 293–312.

    [3] Matthew Love, “Preaching with Newman: Sermonic Vernacular for the Moral Formation of the Church.” (The International Journal of Homiletics, 7:1, 2024): 18. https://doi.org/10.21827/ijh.7.1.18-28

    [4] Mason Lee, “Delighting to Preach: Teaching Towards Affective Formation.” (Homiletic 49:1, 2024): 9.

  • The Nature of being a Witness

    For the fall Graduate School of Theology Covenant Service, I will give the charge to the graduates. The text will be Romans 10, and I will examine the role of confession. The theology of testimony undergirds my theology of preaching. Below are some notes that will influence my charge to the graduates.

    So, what is the role of a witness? Paul Ricoeur identifies four elements of being a witness.

    • The Dialectic of Attestation: Ricoeur sees testimony as a dialectic between “attestation” (the witness’s subjective claim to have experienced or seen an event) and “credibility” (the judgment of the hearer about the reliability of the testimony). One who has seen or heard; one who has experienced an event.
    • The Ethical Dimension: Ricoeur sees testimony as an ethical act, as the witness takes responsibility for their claims. Testimony “commits your life as a confessor to the life and values of the community” – your witness binds you to the declaration.
    • Testimony is not the event itself for it is the hearers of your testimony, the jury (the congregation, community, your fellow travelers), who are called to decide how credible is the testimony. And that element is the Hermeneutical Dimension: For Ricoeur, testimony involves an interpretive element, as the witness must make meaning of their experience and translate it into communicable testimony.
    • And finally, there is the Ontological Dimension: Ricoeur argues that testimony has an ontological dimension as it makes claims about the nature of reality; the very nature of the story we live.[1]

    In “The Hermeneutics of Testimony” (from Essays on Biblical Interpretation), Ricoeur makes several key moves:

    • Ricoeur distinguishes between two levels of testimony:
      • Empirical testimony (what one has seen/experienced)
      • Absolute testimony (commitment to meaning/truth)
    • Ricoeur emphasizes that religious testimony involves both:
      • The historical-empirical (what happened)
      • The confessional-interpretive (what it means)

    In this same work, Ricoeur develops a crucial insight about religious testimony specifically:

    • Unlike legal testimony, which points backward to past events
    • Religious testimony points both:
      • Backward (to founding events)
      • Forward (to future hope)
      • Present (to current meaning/significance)

    In Time and Narrative, Ricoeur further develops how testimony works in religious contexts:

    • Testimony isn’t just reporting facts.
    • Testimony participates in an ongoing narrative.
    • The witness becomes part of the story they’re telling.

    Key Theological Implications:

    • For Understanding Christian Witness:
      • Witness is both historical and confessional.
      • Witness involves both memory and hope.
      • Witness requires both fidelity and interpretation.
    • For Pastoral Practice:
      • Preaching isn’t just reporting past events.
      • Preaching connects past, present, and future (anamnesis and proleptic acts).
      • Preaching involves both telling and living the story.

    Stay tuned. The charge to the graduates is forthcoming.

    [1] The Dialectic of Attestation: Essays on Biblical Interpretation, specifically the essay “The Hermeneutics of Testimony” (1980). In this work, Ricoeur discusses testimony as a dialectic between the witness’s experience and the reception of that testimony. He explores this further in “Oneself as Another” (1992) where he develops his concept of attestation as a form of truth-claim. The Ethical Dimension: “Memory, History, Forgetting” (2004). Ricoeur ties testimony to moral responsibility and ethical commitment, particularly in his discussions of historical testimony and memory. The Hermeneutical Dimension: “Interpretation Theory: Discourse and the Surplus of Meaning” (1976). Also developed in “From Text to Action: Essays in Hermeneutics II” (1991). Here Ricoeur explores how testimony requires interpretation both by the witness and the hearer. The Ontological Dimension: Time and Narrative (Vol. 1-3, 1984-1988). Also discussed in The Rule of Metaphor (1977). Ricoeur connects testimony to reality-claims and narrative identity.

     

  • Narrative and Sermon Design

    Preaching (part 8)

    I will be describing the process of writing a sermon as scripting the plot of the sermon. The easiest way to visualize the script of the sermon’s plot is by using a storyboard. Of the various forms possible, the sermon script below allows flexibility. All sermons preached in my classes must follow the sermon script format. The sermon script resembles the structured episodes found in storyboarding.1 Buttrick calls each episode in the storyboard a “move.” Moves are internally developed primarily using arguments, stories, and images. The storyboard depends upon understanding sermon form as narrative. Narrative is the larger category and “story” is a sub-classification. Of the various ways narrative is used in the literature, I am delimiting the definition to narratival logic or the plotting of thought and action.2 More on the storyboard method below.

    Three Modes of Narrative Plot

    Mode of Immediacy.3 The Mode of Immediacy works primarily with narrative texts. With my emphasis on the rhetorical and narratival structures, I can incorporate this mode easily to all literary genres in the Bible. I do this by emphasizing the present tense. The text presses upon consciousness in the present time. It makes connections as it is being preached to my lived experiences. As the sermon progresses through the plotline, the hearer follows and the connections to live experiences continue through time. We hear and are formed by the performative movement of the text. In the mode of immediacy, plot comes from the text.

    Mode of Reflection: Buttrick prefers the mode of reflection for non-narrative texts. Hebrews is an example. The Hebrew preacher is reflecting on the story of Jesus concisely outlined in Hebrews 1:1-4. The Hebrew preacher is standing back and considering the story as a whole and making the point about Jesus as mediator of a better covenant based on better promises and a greater priesthood, therefore we should remain faithful to our salvation. It is a reflection on the story not as a retelling of the story. The plot of Hebrews is based on reflection of the gospel story and not the gospel genre (Matthew – John). Hebrews has plot and narratival substructure. It uses stories. It utilizes an “exemplar, conclusion, exhortation” logic.4 But it is not told as a story. It is told more like a meditation, “a word of exhortation.”

    Mode of Praxis: I handle the Mode of Praxis by incorporating action throughout the sermon. I do not make this a separate category or mode at all. Function statements have strong verbs with behavioral and affective ends. Belief and action in concrete situations are bound and cannot be separated. How one lives in the world as a Christian and how the text/reflected theology connects to our world is the same to me. Here is where Buttrick is the most ahistorical. He does not need a text but only a theological field of meaning. Theological fields of meaning bear witness to situations that affect Christian behavior. He is right. We do this all the time. He is making it overt. However, for me, I want to make the connection between the text and the text’s witness to theology overt. In the Mode of Praxis, the plot comes from the situation of our lives and how a field of meaning addresses that situation.

    Plotline of Sermon: A plotline, another word for sequence or arrangement, is a way to follow the flow or movement of the episodes of the sermon from the beginning to the ending. Indicate if the sermon is in the mode of immediacy or the mode of reflection. To compose a plotline, write a paragraph consisting of the first sentences of each move (sometimes it might be the first two sentences of an episode). When writing the plotline paragraph, separate the first sentences of each move using an asterisk (*). In other words, write a paragraph that includes a copy and paste of the first sentences of each episode/move.5

    Concluding Hints for Storyboarding

    1. H. Abrams, Glossary of Literary Terms. “The plot in a dramatic or narrative work is the structure of its actions as these are ordered and rendered toward achieving a particular emotional and artistic effect.”
    2. Scripting the whole sermon by way of plot will also require you to pay attention to sequencing thought within each episode.
    3. Sermons come alive using concrete, significant detail that is appropriate for the audience’s experiences. Abstractions communicate understanding but appealing to the five senses motivates the soul. The old writer’s cliche is true, “show, don’t tell.” For example, teaching someone to drive a clutch on grandpa’s rusty pickup in the K-Mart parking lot communicates more than “it is like learning to drive.” A concretization is a story or image that enables people to experience the gospel in the present For example, what illustrations do I use to communicate the theology of transformation? Many preachers opt for the illustration of a butterfly’s metamorphous life cycle. But does talking about caterpillars make any difference to Agnes on Tuesday? She may understand the theory better, but does cognitive clarity change her heart? Instead, find a concretization about the transforming power of God in someone’s life.
    4. Think about a sermon as a road map that is seeking a destination. Go down this road, take this turn, stop here, and turn left, then right, until you reach your goal. A map is like a directed, purposeful conversation that follows not the rules of logic but the less predictable contours of human Each new road you take when following directions is an episode. There might be a different set of directions that would get you where you are going, but that would be a different route or a different plotting of the directions. The model of a road map is a conversation that is headed toward a conclusion. You are trying to get somewhere. The quality of the end of one idea suggests the turn to a new idea; therefore, the turns or transitions are important. You always start with the end in mind. Once you reach your destination, STOP! Don’t park next door, don’t circle the block seven times, simply stop because you have arrived at your destination.
    5. Moves are more like a movie than a picture book. The arrangement of thought is more conversational in development; it is a series of interlinked assertions, not proofs. It is a combination of deductive and inductive There is a thesis but, because it is a
      metaphor, you don’t know what the movie means until the end. Although the sermon is teeming with images, arguments, examples, and stories, the scaffolding of the progression is simple.

    Sermon Script Format

    Sermon Title

    (Sermon Text)

    Rhetorical and Theological Argument of the Text: Approximately 200 – 300-word summary. Identify the form and function of the genre. If the pericope has a significant literary device (e.g., parallelisms, inclusio, diatribe, chiasmus, etc.), then describe how the device is working.

    Focus Statement of Sermon: A theologically-oriented subject and an active verb that states what the sermon is all about. Be clear and concise.

    Function Statement of Sermon: The sermon’s intent. Naming the “hoped for change.” Format: “To [strong behavioral or affective verb] [identify the audience] to [second active verb] …” Be clear and concise.

    [Core Affirmation: An alternative to the Focus and Function Statement given above: What difference does the Divine action of God make in our world of experience? Format: “Because God has acted [is acting/promises to act] in the following way–[therefore]–we are able to do the following … (the sentence finishes with a brief description of some faithful action ow made possible for us in the word ‘opened up’ by God’s action).”]

    Plotline of Sermon: A paragraph consisting of the first sentences of each move. Indicate if the sermon is in the mode of immediacy or the mode of reflection. When writing the plotline, separate the moves using an asterisk (*). [First sentence from the introduction. *First sentence from Move 1. *First sentence from Move 2. * First sentence from Move 3. *Etc.].

    Describe: Mode of Reflection or Mode of Immediacy, Point of Entry, & Point of View

    Script

    Introductions indicate intention toward but do not solve or provide resolution. Makes a promise to the hearer about the nature and focus of sermon. Should indicate the direction the sermon will take. The need for the sermon, the “itch” (antithesis, trouble, or tension) is highlighted. The introduction is a transition from the liturgical setting to Move 1.

    Move/Episode 1 [Do not use a sub-heading to name the Moves].

      • The transition or connector.1 First sentence of the move [same as the first sentence of your plotline].
      • Description of the move indicating development: argument, image, and/or story (50 words). 2
      • Closing sentence [an inclusio of the first sentence of the move]. Make sure you affect closure of an episode before transitioning to the next.

    Move/Episode 2

      • transition: First sentence of the move [same as the second sentence of your plotline].
      • Description of the move indicating development: argument, image, and/or story (50 words).
      • Closing sentence [an inclusio of the first sentence of the move].

    Repeat the pattern for the remaining moves and/or episodes.

      • transition: First sentence of the move [same as the next sentence of your plotline].
      • Description of the move indicating development: argument, image, and/or story (50 words).
      • Closing sentence [an inclusio of the first sentence of the move].

    Last paragraph of the conclusion: The climax must cohere with the focus and function statements.

    1The transition is a connector. A connector could be a pause, a repeated refrain, a transitional phrase, a summary statement that completes one move and leads to the next, or a transitional story or example. Often, transitions are the most difficult parts of sermons to write, and if you find that you cannot find an appropriate connector to tie two parts of a sermon together, then the problem may lie in the logical flow of the sermon.

        • Make sure there is closure before you transition to something new.
        • Transitions point to the path, the direction you are heading.
        • Transitions connect to the next (and, but, yet, if, then, reconsider, etc.)
        • Transitions anticipate content of the next step in the homiletical journey.

    2 Include 4–7 analytical footnotes explaining why you do what you do (specifically relating to, theology, exegesis, genre, and homiletical method). Include 4 – 7 footnotes connecting the sermon to a specific contextual analysis.

    ______________________

    1. See STORYBOARD for a link to various templates. Or simply use Google images and search for “storyboard” or “storyboard ” Also see David L. Barnhart & L. Susan Bond, “Homiletix: Using Comics to Teach Buttrick’s Model.”
    2. Ronald Allen, “Theology Undergirding Narrative Preaching,” in What the Shape of Narrative Preaching? Edited by Mike Graves and David J. Schlafer (St. Louis: Chalice, 2008), 27–28. See my examples of Buttrick’s modes in “Preaching Ephesians: The Fourfold Fountain of God” Restoration Quarterly 62 (Second Quarter 2020): 81–97. My articles in Restoration Quarterly can be found at https://digitalcommons.acu.edu/restorationquarterly/
    3. Narrative Modes comes from Buttrick, Homiletic, 333-448. Examples of the modes of immediacy and reflection are found in my article “How Lonely Stands the Preacher.” Restoration Quarterly 59 (Fourth Quarter 2017): 234-
    4. Wills, “The Form of the Sermon in Hellenistic Judaism and Early Christianity,” 277–99.
    5. Examples of focus statements, function statements, plotlines, and manuscripts are found in “Preaching Ephesians,” 81–97.

     

  • Preaching Narratively

    Preaching (part 7)

    The traditional homiletic that developed during the Enlightenment follows a deductive logic and is often given the shorthand description of Point 1, Point 2, Point 3. Often, but not always, the deductive sequence arrangement is static. It does not move towards a conclusion. A way to test if the traditional arrangement has movement is to rearrange the points. If the sequence of the points does not matter, then the sermon is static in the presentation of the material. The New Homiletic addresses how the listener experiences the sermon.1 Craddock used stories as a way for the audience to experience the movement of the sermon like the way the Bible itself preaches. Craddock did this often through inductive logic or indirect speech. More so than any other way, the New Homiletic embraced narrative to present the sequence of the content in a dynamic way. Grady Davis says,

    There is one compelling reason, among other reasons, why I shall not rely on the word “outline” to designate the plan of a sermon. The conventional outline is a static and visual plan, whereas the sermon can be properly planned only as an audible movement in time. The proper plan of a sermon, then, the proper sketch of a sermon, the proper design of a sermon, is the design of a time-continuity. And so I shall prefer to speak of the continuity or the movement of a sermon, rather than of its outline…A sermon is a continuity of sounds, looks, gestures, which follow one another in time. A sermon is not static like a painting. A painting shows itself as a whole in a single instant…A sermon is like a play, not the printed book but the action on a stage, which moves from a first act through a second to a third, and the drama is never seen all at once. A sermon is like a story told aloud, where each sentence has gone forever into the past before the next is spoken…Once I have worked my idea through in its structure and its development, in its generals and its particulars, I can see it all at once in my mind. It is then like a picture to me…If there is ever to be a complete picture in the preacher’s mind, he has to see where each piece fits and put the picture together for himself.2

    Plot is the strategic sequencing of (events, musical notes, arguments, images, actions, etc.) through time. For example, if you rearrange the notes, you change the song. Eugene Lowry has the example of a song that gathers all the same notes together (AAAACCDDDDFFFFFFGGGBbF#F#) without thought to the arrangement. But when he rearranges the notes, you have “Amazing Grace.” Form matters. And that leads us to consider the plot, a narrative device that arranges the form.

    Narrative & Movement: While your destination is discerned first during the exegetical process, you do not begin the sermon on Sunday at the end. The sermon will begin at the beginning. The sermon is not static like a painting but flows moment by moment through time. The metaphor is not the score of notes on a page but the live performance of the music.3 The movement of the words through time is plotted sequence that moves from here to there – beginning to end. In the homiletical journey, do not leave the listeners behind.

    Aristotle, in POETICS (http://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/poetics.html),4 identified the plot as moving from conflict (tension) to complication (the plot thickens) to climax to denouement. Or as Eugene Lowry often says, “from itch to scratch.”5 Reversal is a key term in plotting and an essential element to the theological goal of transformation. Often the terms Orientation, Disorientation, Reorientation are used to describe moving an audience from where they are to where you intend to take them.

    Foster-Harris6 – recommendations for telling a story that simplifies Aristotle’s Poetics. He emphasizes the reversal aspect of plot.

      1. Action in narrative is often experienced as conflict. Set the situation and characters in place with no flashbacks until the action is well underway, making sure that you start with action having already Do not begin with description that has no action. Use description only to serve action. [Sensing’s Note: the character to first consider is God (Father, Son, Spirit); the action, God’s action.]
      2. Develop some complication at the beginning arising from the internal conflict and the character’s decisions and actions. Do not discuss the emotions; simply show the signs of the emotions in a character’s actions or appearance.
      3. Move to a crisis in which the character makes a
      4. Conclude with the resolution (denouement) of the climax.

    Lowry’s Loop is a shorthand way to describe the plot and is sometimes illustrated as a Valley Sermon. Both images reflect movement and flow. Lowry, Homiletical Plot (1980); Doing Time in the Pulpit (1985); The Sermon: Dancing the Edge of Mystery (1997) describe the Loop as a narrative plot.

      1. Upsetting the Equilibrium
      2. Analyzing the Discrepancy
      3. Disclosing the Clue to Resolution
      4. Experiencing the Gospel
      5. Anticipating the Consequences

    Compare to A.H. Monroe’s (1948) Motivated Sequence. It consists of five steps:

      1. Attention: Get the attention of your audience using a detailed story, shocking example, dramatic statistic, quotations, etc.
      2. Need: Show that the problem about which you are speaking exists, that it is significant, and that it won’t go away by Use statistics, examples, etc. Convince your audience that there is a need for action to be taken.
      3. Satisfy: You need to solve the Provide specific and viable solutions that the government or communities can implement to solve the problem.
      4. Visualization: Tell the audience what will happen if the solution is implemented or does not take place. Be visual and detailed.
      5. Action: Tell the audience what action they can take personally to solve the

    The advantage of Monroe’s Motivated Sequence is that it emphasizes what the audience can do. Too often, the audience feels like a situation is hopeless; Monroe’s motivated sequence emphasizes the action the audience can take. Lowry’s Loop sees the Motivated Sequence as a way to provide sermons with narrative logic.

    This series on preaching will conclude next week with part 8, Narrative and Sermon Design.

    __________________

    1. Reid, Fleer, and Bullock, “Preaching as the Creation of an Experience,” 1–9.
    2. Davis, Design for Preaching, 12; 163–64.
    3. Davis, Design for Preaching, 163–164. Davis’s text in 1958 moves away from the idea of “outline” when conceiving of a The classic text is often cited as the beginning of a movement called the “New Homiletic.” See Sensing, “After the Craddock Revolution,” 211–219.
    4. Sensing, “Aristotle’s Poetics,” http://www.homiletic.net/index.php/homiletic/
    5. Lowry, The Homiletical Plot, 15–21. The “Lowry Loop” is a description of a common homiletical form that is seen in various textbooks and is summarized concisely by Allen, Determining the Form.
    6. Foster-Harris, The Basic Patterns of Plot.
  • Preaching Essentials

    Preaching (part 6)

    As noted in a previous blog, “sermons are not propelled by powerful beginnings but are evoked by significant ends.” What is that significant end? What is the living theology found in the biblical text that transforms the congregation and will make a difference in the lives of the listeners on Monday? What is the theological live wire? Exegesis uncovers the text’s significant end.

    The sermon writing process begins by stating the theological claim of the text you discovered through exegetical analysis. The preacher will want to say and do in the present tense what the text said and did in the past tense. The theological claim of the text informs the sermon about where the sermon is going and what the sermon is doing. What the theological claim is saying is often called the sermon’s focus. What the theological claim is doing theologically is often called the sermon’s function.

    While not intuitive, the focus and function of the sermon are precise statements that indicate the destination of the sermon, the denouement of the plot, or the sermon’s conclusion. Write those two statements in bold print in the concluding paragraph of your sermon. You may rephrase them to fit the rhetorical needs of the conclusion, but their presence must remain clear.

    The sermon is sequenced to lead the audience from an introduction to that conclusion. [Sequence is described in part 7 of this series.] The conclusion of a sermon is proof that the focus is maintained and the function realized.1

    Focus Statement of the Sermon: The format of the function statement includes a theologically oriented subject, an active verb, and the predicate that states what the sermon is addressing. Be clear and concise. If you are not sure what the theological subject is you can always start with God as your subject followed by an active verb. “God blesses…” “God gives…” “God invites…” For example, “God’s love embraces all people.” The focus statement is your locutionary act.

    Function Statement of the Sermon: The function statement names the sermon’s intent— names the “hoped for change.” Format: “To [strong behavioral or affective verb] [identify the audience] to [second active verb]…” Be clear and concise. For example, “To encourage the congregation to embrace loving enemies.” The function statement performs your illocutionary and perlocutionary acts.

    Core Affirmations: [An alternative to the Focus and Function Statements] A Core Affirmation is a single, declarative sentence that announces what God has done, is doing, or promises yet to do and then names the difference this makes in the world of our hearers. What difference does the divine action of God make in our world of experience? Once the divine action is named, then Core Affirmations move to the difference this divine action makes for the human situation. This is where the call to action comes into play. And this is where the emphasis on invitation and participation comes into play – by starting with what God has done, is doing, or will do, the call for action made in the sermon becomes one of joining the work of God.2  Format: “Because God has acted [is acting/promises to act] in the following way – [therefore] – we are able to do the following…(the sentence finishes with a brief description of some faithful action now made possible for us in the word opened up by God’s action).”3 [Note: Core Affirmations are missing the function verb found above in Function Statements].

    So, if the statement is true, “Sermons are not propelled by powerful beginnings but are evoked by significant ends,” then the following statements are also true:

    1. Conclusions are formed by your focus and function statements (or the Core Affirmation). In the conclusion of the sermon, did you say and do what you set out to say and do? Does the conclusion cohere with the theological aim/claim of the sermon?
    2. Conclusions conclude. If your meaning has not yet been heard before now [the conclusion], it is too late for it to be heard now. Know your conclusion before you write the sermon. Know your destination before you begin your journey.
    3. Conclusions fulfill purpose. Does the sermon do what it intends to do? Conclusions cohere with focus and function. Conclusions achieve the anticipated climax. Conclusions are governed by your intentions.
    4. Affect a closure. When you get to the end of your sermon, stop. When you arrive at your destination, park your car. The sermon needs to end! Therefore, use direct, simple, concrete language.
    5. Build connections to response. Be direct and personal. Convince people that the message is related to their lived experiences. Be passionate that the theology of the sermon matters. Be hopeful and expectant. Trust the people to do right.
    6. Responses may vary. There is more than one way and one time to respond to a sermon.
    7. AND, most importantly, the conclusion of the sermon is fully alive when the live wire of theology electrifies the words. The conclusion is formed by the theological claim of the text.

    AND, if that is how you write a conclusion, how do you write your introduction? “Light your match on the first strike.” Plato stated the obvious centuries ago. Every piece of written or oral communication must have a beginning, middle, and end. Many sermons flop because many preachers do not know where they are or where they’re going. Introductions, likewise, are dependent on the purpose of the sermon, the theological claim of the text.

    1. Introductions Set the Stage – How will you handle or talk about certain things in certain ways? Introductions need to be interesting, raise issues, and be memorable. In this way, introductions orient the congregation to the theological claim. Give the listener the ability to anticipate what the sermon is about. You can do this fully, or only with a hint, but somehow say, “here is the path.” Anticipate the whole and show the next step. Point toward the focus and function of the sermon. Promise something the hearers want you to keep. It needs to bear on their lives. The promise should be of value to the congregation.
    2. Introductions Communicate a Contract with the Audience – What you can you expect?
    3. Appropriate Language and Tone – The language and tone of the introduction should create a fair expectation of the language and tone of the sermon.
    4. Introductions are Transitions – While the introduction should anticipate the whole sermon, it should also lead directly to the next step of the sermon’s sequence. The value of the introduction is how it functions in the sermon. It is a journey beginning “here” with the concept of “there” in mind. Where will this sermon go? Get on with the mission.
    5. Prepare Introductions Last – Prepare after the body of the sermon and the conclusion.

    _______

    1. While my use of focus and function  statements resembles Long’s Witness of Preaching, I am making substantial shifts in his approach.
    2. Lee, Class Presentation. Dr. Sally Brown’s Definition of Preaching… “A Christian sermon is a theo-rhetorical act anchored in Christian scripture that declares to particular listeners in a particular time and place some aspect of what God has done, is doing, and promises yet to do, to make all things new.”
    3. Brown and Powery, The Ways of the Word, 142.