Category: Teaching

  • Apostles’ Creed (part 8)

    On May 11, Mother’s Day, I conclude my series at the Highland Church of Christ. On this day, I remember my mother, who died in 2024. I also remember my father. May 11 is his birthday. He died in 2018. Blessed are the dead who die in the Lord (Rev. 14:13). If we have died with Christ, we shall also live with him (Rom. 6:8).

    The resurrection of the body. // And the life everlasting. Amen.

      • The Creed ends with the fullness of our future salvation. It is “consistently pictured as a time when justice and peace will be finally established, the high and mighty brought low, and the lowly lifted up.”[1]
      • That which is true of Jesus is true for us. The telos of his life on earth is our telos too.
      • “Your kingdom come, on earth as it is in heaven. In other words, ‘entering’ the kingdom is a matter of entering into God’s sovereign rule, submitting to that rule, and seeing it played out in the word in which we live, whether that is now, already, or in some presumed future lying beyond death.”[2] It is picture not as a place we go but a life and future that which comes to us, on earth, a place where God will himself fully be at home in his creation. Bringing God’s glorious purpose of creation to its fulfilment.
      • “In the degree to which Christianity cut itself off from its Hebrew roots and acquired Hellenistic and Roman form, it lost its eschatological hope and surrendered its apocalyptic alternative to ‘this world’ of violence and death. It merged into late antiquity’s gnostic religion of redemption. … God’s eternity now took the place of God’s future, heaven replaced the coming kingdom, the spirit that redeems the soul from the body supplanted the Spirit as ‘the well of life,’ the immortality of the soul displaced the resurrection of the body, and yearning for another world became a substitute for changing this one.”[3]
      • “Have we become terrified of dying? We do all in our power, it seems, to glorify youth and avoid death. “Blessed are the dead who die in the Lord. If we have died with Christ, we shall also live with him. We commemorate the saints, not on the day of their birth, but rather on the day of their death. Our coming into the world matters far less than our going from it—our passage into eternal life. In our death, our lives are meant to reach their completion and fulfillment in Christ.”[4]
        • Some say, “there is no resurrection of the dead (anastasis nekron)” (1 Cor. 15:12): no raising of corpses. 1 Cor. 15 is a response. No! Paul says, we believe in the resurrection.
          • When we speak of believing in the resurrection of the body, the question is asked, “How can there be both continuity and transformation?”
          • 1 Cor. 15:50 “flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of God.” The resurrection involves both the continuity with our present embodied existence and the transformation of our bodies into a glorified state beyond our imagining (1 Cor. 15:52).
        • And just as in 1 Cor. 15, it involves the redemption of our bodies (Rom. 8:23).
        • See earlier posts about the bodily resurrection of Jesus.
      • Life everlasting = eternal life or quality of life, fullness of life (John 10:10; 11:25–26).
        • Not “wishful thinking” or “too good to be true.”
        • “So Luther’s wise counsel: ‘As little children in their womb know about their birth, so little do we know about life everlasting.’”[5]
        • 1 Jn. 3:2.
        • The eternal quality of love.
    1. “Amen.” “So it is strange that we end the creed by pronouncing a solemn ‘amen.; To say amen to the creed is to sign my mane to it. I confirm the truth of this: I authorize it: amen. Yet we barely fathom what we are saying in the creed. How could anyone have the power to say amen to all this?”[6]
      • Or do we wink or cross our fingers on certain lines of the creed?
      • 2 Cor 1:18–20. “The whole creed is about God’s action God’s agency, God’s initiative. Even at the end, when we pronounce the amen, we are drawing not on our own resource but God’s. We are participating in the action of Jesus, who looks into the face of God and sees all God’s ways and works, and says: ‘Yes! Amen!’ When we say the creed, we echo his might and eternal amen with our own small hopeful voices.”[7]
      • If the Creed is performative, then how does it shape and form us (individually and/or communally)? Over time, what transformative action do we see in our lives? What is promised? What is fulfilled?

    The grace of the Lord Jesus Christ, the love of God, and the communion of the Holy Spirit be with all of you (2 Cor 13:13).


    [1] Hart, Confessing and Believing, 276.

    [2] Hart, Confessing and Believing, 279.

    [3] Jürgen Moltmann, The Spirit of Life: A Universal Affirmation. Trans. Margaret Kohl, 3rd ed. (Minneapolis: Fortress, 1992), 306.

    [4] Ralph C. Wood, “The Call of the Crucified,” 111, in Van Harn, Exploring & Proclaiming the Apostles’ Creed.

    [5] Quoted by Gabriel Fackre, “The Life Everlasting,” 280, in Van Harn, Exploring & Proclaiming the Apostles’ Creed.

    [6] Myers, The Apostles’ Creed, 131.

    [7] Myers, The Apostles’ Creed, 132.

  • Apostles’ Creed (part 7)

    I believe in the holy catholic church. // The communion of saints. The forgiveness of sins.

      • The story of the Triune God is our story. “Jesus did not write a book but formed a community.”[1] Conversion is to the Lordship of Jesus where we find our identity. Our identity is found in community (1 Cor. 12:12–13). Although many of us find places in multiple communities all vying for our loyalties.
      • It is one, holy, catholic, and apostolic.
        • One: This refers to the unity of the Church, meaning it is a single body with Christ as its head. The church is united by love and shared beliefs. The body of Christ is the most inclusive community imaginable. Eph 4:1–4.
        • Holy: This means the Church is set apart for God and reflects his holiness. While its members may sin, the Church as a whole is considered sacred because of its connection to Christ and the Holy Spirit.
          • See John 17:17; Col. 1:22; 3:12; Eph. 1:4; 4:23–24; Heb. 12:14; 1 Thess. 4:7; 2 Tim. 1:9; 2 Pet. 3:11).
          • The church is holy (Eph. 2:21; 5:26–27; 1 Pet. 2:5).
        • Catholic: It indicates that the Church’s teachings and mission are for all people, in all places, at all times.
            • The church in the NT is represented as autonomous bodies held together by a common faith in Jesus Christ.
            • The third mark, “catholic,” stems from the Greek word“katholikos,” which essentially means “on the whole” or “universal.” Catholics, Protestants, and Evangelicals are united, in a sense, on the catholicity of the Church because “the body of Christ is universal” and [all] faith traditions are united in the belief that God’s “love knows no boundaries; his offer of salvation has no limits.” “Mission, service, leadership, and proclamation further the catholicity of the Church.” “In this work, … it is God in Christ who accomplishes catholicity, which is present in every community gathered in his name.”[2]
              • Saint Cyril of Jerusalem (ca. 350 says, “It is denominated Catholic because it extends over all the world, from one end of the earth to the other; and because it teaches universally and completely one and all the doctrines which ought to come to men’s knowledge, concerning things both visible and invisible, heavenly and earthly; and because it brings into subjection to godliness the whole race of mankind, governors and governed, learned and unlearned; and because it  universally treats and heals the whole class of sins,  which are committed by soul or body, and possesses in itself every form of virtue which is named, both in deeds and words, and in every kind of spiritual gifts.”[3]
              • John Zizioulas defines “catholicity” as “the fullness of communion.” A local congregation must be in full communion with the rest of the local churches in the world in order to be truly a church.[4]
            • What are the possible divisions and/or gaps between people?
              • Social, Gender, Doctrine, Race, Power, Politics,
              • “The greatest barrier is death. It splits the human family into the two classes of the living and the dead.” [5] All other divisions are petty compared to the division between the living and the dead.
              • But no matter what the division, all are mysteriously united in one Spirit. Baptism unites us all. A singular gospel unites us all. The resurrection unites us all, even the living and the dead.
        • Apostolic: This signifies that the Church’s teachings and authority are directly linked to the apostles, who were chosen by Jesus. Therefore, the church is the only authentic witness of the Gospel.
    • Communion of the Saints: koinonia is used 38 times in the NT. It is not a term found in the OT or by Jesus. It’s first occurrence is found in 1 Corinthians.[6]
      • “The noun koinonia has a considerable range of meanings in the New Testament. It can mean (1) close association involving mutual interests and sharing, translated as ‘association,’ ‘communion,’ ‘fellowship,’ ‘close relationship’ (Phil. 1:5; Rom. 15:26); (2) an attitude of good will that manifests an interest in a close relationship translated as generosity (2 Cor. 9:13); (3) an abstract term for the concrete ‘sign of fellowship, proof of brotherly unity, or gift or contribution’ (Rom. 15:26; 1 Cor. 10:16); or (4) participation or sharing in something: Christ’s sufferings (Phil. 3:10), the body and blood of Christ (1 Cor. 10:16), the Holy Spirit (2 Cor. 13:13), faith (Philem. 6).”[7]
      • The closest phrase to the “communion of the saints” might be “a cloud of witnesses” (Heb. 12:1).
      • The Latin phrase is grammatically ambiguous. Another translation could be “a sharing or partaking in holy things.” Such a translation is a reference to the Eucharist. But this is not mutually exclusive as seen in 1 Cor. 10:16–17. [8]
    • Forgiveness:
      • When we are wronged, it often happens within community. It is fitting that forgiveness comes here within the creed.
      • Even in denial and apostacy, forgiveness is found. In 303 Diocletian ordered a mass persecution. But if you offered sacrifice, you would be safe. You could do the sacrifice en masse. Eventually, as things returned to normal, apostates returned seeking fellowship again.
      • Silence and the continual return of Kichijiro.

    “Throughout the story, Kichijiro repeatedly apostatizes, then repents, and then apostatizes again. The first time Kichijiro repents, Rodrigues is touched. “Your faith gives me strength,” he says. But Kichijiro increasingly disgusts Rodrigues; he doesn’t believe Kichijiro’s faith is real, because he keeps denying Christ. Yet in that first confession scene, Kichijiro says something interesting. He says, “My love for God is strong. Could that be the same as faith?” Rodrigues says, “Yes.” It is enough to love God, even if you are too weak to remain faithful, because God is faithful when you are not. Kichijiro laments that he happened to be born during a time of persecution. If he had been born a hundred years earlier, he notes, it would have been easy to be a Christian. Rodrigues wonders, “Where is the place for a weak man in a world like this?” But as Silence continues, we are reminded that the gospel is precisely that Jesus died for the weak and sinful, those who do not deserve forgiveness.”[9]

      • The forgiveness of sins has taken place once for all in the death and resurrection of Jesus. God is all about forgiveness due to God’s great love, grace, and mercy. Forgiveness is the function of God’s holiness. Forgiveness (salvation) is a means to restore human fellowship with God. The story of God is mostly about God’s action to provide redemption through the means of forgiveness.
      • What is stronger than the blood of Jesus? How effective is forgiveness? Once for all (2 Cor. 5:14; Rom. 5:8)?
      • Pastoral Care Case: A woman who asked the minister to pray for her forgiveness of adultery routinely and repeatedly. Maybe this was in response to an unforgiving spouse. Maybe she could not forgive herself. Maybe there were other psychological or social factors. But the fear that we are unforgiven despite having sought forgiveness in the acts of confession, penitence, and faith [10] still haunts us. It deadens our love, joy, and peace. Therefore, forgiveness must be freely received as a gift.
      • Is the notion, all you must do is confess, repent, and believe transactional in nature? Is it just “if-then” logic that festers into fear, lack of assurance, and dread?[11] Do we have to present ourselves as “forgivable”? Is forgiveness conditional?
      • Theologically, how effective is the blood? How powerful is God’s love? And to understand confession and repentance as a radical acceptance and response of appreciation to what God has done for us in Jesus Christ!
      • What does the Lord’s Prayer “Forgive our debts as we forgive our debtors” mean to us? For it is through God’s forgiveness that we learn to embody forgiveness.
      • See also Eph. 4:32.
      • So, our forgiving others is a regifting of God’s gift. And that gift is without price. There is no transactional act (no legal repentance required). “Freely you have received, so now you give to others freely” (Matt. 10:8).
      • Only love can transform us into people who forgive others’ debts.
      • And yet, forgiving does not mean forgetting. Acknowledgement is foremost when confessing, repenting, and receiving forgiveness. Forgiving is taking the offense, sin, and pain seriously. How can we move forward so that the wrongs are not repeated? Being forgiven changes us. Forgiving changes the relationship I have with the pain and with the other person.
      • The church is not a place of spiritual elitism but a place where we all come together and hear the confession, “I believe in the forgiveness of sins.”

    [1] Leslie Newbigin, The Gospel in a Pluralist Society, 227.

    [2] CNA, Catholic News Agency, Accessed April 9, 2025. See also First Things, March 25, 2025.

    [3] Catechetical Lecture 18.23 (Patrologia Graeca, 22:1044), cited by Susan K. Wood, “The Holy Catholic Church, the Communion of the Saints,” 225, in Van Harn, Exploring & Proclaiming the Apostles’ Creed.

    [4] John Zizioulas, Being as Communion: Studies in Personhood and the Church (New York: St. Vladimir’s Seminary Press, 1985), 257–59 cited by Wood, “The Holy Catholic Church,” 227.

    [5] Myers, The Apostles’ Creed, 105.

    [6] Wood, “The Holy Catholic Church,” 221.

    [7] Wood, “The Holy Catholic Church,” 221.

    [8] Wood, “The Holy Catholic Church,” 227.

    [9] https://www.equip.org/articles/the-hidden-faith-of-silence/

    [10] Hart, Confessing and Believing, 258.

    [11] Hart, Confessing and Believing, 258.

  • Apostles’ Creed (part 6)

    And I believe in the Holy Spirit.

      • As we have discussed, much of trinitarian thought is more mystery than rational, logical, or substantiated science. That should not surprise us, for we have been there before. What is new here in terms of faith and “the assurance of things hoped for, and the conviction of things not seen. … By faith we understand that the worlds were prepared by the word of God, so that what is seen was made from things that are not visible” (Heb 11:1). Take for instance, creation, the virgin birth, resurrection, the ascension, the Trinity, and today’s topic, the Holy Spirit.
        • This is not 2+2=4 faith.
        • While not beyond the reach and realm of reason, faith is more about trust. We know more about faith by the implications it has for our lives and the assurance we have.
      • John Wesley is known for talking about “his warm feeling.” “Christian experience”—the experience of “assurance” as seen in the oft-quoted line, “In the evening I went very unwillingly to a society in Aldersgate Street, where one was reading Luther’s ‘Preface to the Epistle to the Romans’. About a quarter before nine, while he was describing the change which God works in the heart through faith in Christ, I felt my heart strangely warmed. I felt I did trust in Christ, Christ alone for salvation, and an assurance was given me that he had taken away my sins, even mine, and saved me from the law of sin and death.”[1]
      • Experience includes the individual’s direct experience of God’s love, forgiveness, and the witness of the Spirit confirming their adoption as children of God. This is often referred to as the “assurance of salvation” or the “witness of the Spirit.” Wesley emphasized the role of the Holy Spirit in bearing witness to one’s faith, leading to a distinctively Christian experience of assurance.“The Spirit himself testifies with our spirit that we are God’s children” (Rom 8:16). Evidence of God’s saving act is seen in the sanctification and transformation in the life of the believer (e.g., the fruits of the Spirit). While personal experience is also understood within the context of the Christian community. The shared experiences of God’s work among believers, their testimonies, and the collective wisdom of the faithful contribute to theological understanding. Wesley valued the accounts of others’ encounters with God, particularly within the Methodist societies. Additionally, Wesley valued discernment. He did not see experience as an autonomous source of truth. Instead, it must be consistent with Scripture, informed by tradition,[2] and examined by reason. If a personal or communal experience contradicts these other sources, its theological validity is questioned.
      • And so too is our fully trinitarian faith seen in the Holy Spirit—“the Father sending his Son into the world for all; the Son in his life, death and resurrection offering our shared humanity to the Father in the Spirit’s power; and the Holy Spirit working in the world, in the church, and in us to kindle that faith that alone grasps and responds appropriately to the reality of what has occurred.”[3]
        • 2 Cor. 3:17.
        • “The Holy Spirit is differentiated from the Father as one who proceeds … from the Father. In the New Testament the Holy Spirit is also differentiated from Jesus, who both promises the Spirit (John 14:26) and is raised by the Spirit (Rom. 1:4). The Holy Spirit is not regarded as a creature because “to proceed from” is not the same as “to be created by,” and because the Holy Spirit is worshiped … and glorified together with the Father and the Son.”[4]
    • We proclaim the Apostles’ Creed, “I believe in the Holy Spirit.” The Apostles’ Creed though has more to say than that one line. Earlier it says, “And in Jesus Christ, his only begotten Son, our Lord, Who was conceived by the Holy Spirit.” The Spirit’s role in conception intrigues me. Creation itself was conceived by the Holy Spirit as the Spirit hovered over the waters of chaos (Gen 1:1–2). God breathes spirit into the clay, and it becomes a living being (Gen 2:7). The Psalmist proclaims, “When you send forth our spirit, they are created.” God’s Spirit directly conceives new beginnings. God’s Spirit is at the heart of our Creator God.
      • And the road continues. Isa. 32:15 God’s Spirit is poured out over all flesh connected to the restoration of (or resurrected life of) Israel. See also Isa 11:2; 51:11; 61:1; 63:10–11; Ezek. 37:7–14; and Joel 2:28). The Holy Spirit brings about restoration and is connected to the holiness of God and the holiness required of God’s people.
      • “So when the Spirit broods over the womb of Mary, we see a picture of God’s creative work happening all over again.”[5] And the story continues with Elizabeth (Lk 1:41). And the power of the Spirit brought life again in the resurrection of Jesus (Rom 1:4). The Nicaean Creed is clear on this very point, “And I believe in the Holy Spirit, the Lord and Giver of Life.”
      • And it is the same Spirit (Acts 1:12; 2:1–4) where we find the conception of the Church. Acts is sometimes called the Gospel of the Holy Spirit. The Spirit’s active agency is experienced by the Church in wondrous and beautiful ways. Acts 1:8 restoration of Israel.
        • Ruach/pneuma—spirit, breath, or wind. And just as our own breath is embodied, separate but one, so too is the breath or Spirit of God. We may differentiate between the two, perhaps, but we cannot separate the two.[6] Again, we know this, as in concepts like body, soul, spirit, and mind. We too embody that breath with the indwelling of God Holy Spirit within us. In creation (Gen 2:7) and our new birth (John 3:3–5), and the birth of the church (Acts 2).
        • Both individually and communally, 1 Cor 3 & 6. “For in the one Spirit we were all baptized into one body—Jews or Greeks, slaves or free—and we were all made to drink of one Spirit” (1 Cor. 12:13).
        • The key descriptor of the Spirit is “Holy.” The Holy Spirit of Jesus is the Holy Spirit of the church.
        • In contrast to any other spirit or spirit of this age.
      • The resurrection brought about the coming of the Holy Spirit in Acts 2. The Spirit proleptically provides all the fullness that resurrection life brings us.
        • The Holy Spirit is a deposit, the first installment of the fullness of our salvation.
        • 2 Cor. 1:22; 2 (Cor. 5:5; Eph. 1:13–1). When I buy a car on a 48-month term, I get the full use and privileges of the car. The same with a deposit and mortgage on a house.
        • And the verdict is “Yes” and “Amen.” See 2 Cor. 1:19–20 as it leads to 1:22.
        • See also Rom. 8:10–11.
      • And just as God incarnated God’s self in Jesus materially, God embodies us with God’s indwelling Spirit. Hart quotes C. S. Lewis in Mere Christianity (48, 88) saying, “‘God likes matter. He invented it.’ God invented matter so that God might make it God’s own, “sharing I its life fully and personally so that we in our turn might come to share at last in God’s life, God’s joy, Gd’s glory and do so in a manner that is bodlily just as surely as it is spiritual.” [7]
      • “The phrases ‘in Christ’ and ‘in the Spirit’ are synonyms because, after the ascension the presence of one would be incomprehensible apart from the presence of the other.”[8]
      • “The early church expressed the complexity of the two introductory copulas by affirming that the Son is ‘begotten’ while the Spirit ‘proceeds’ from the Father and the Son together or from the Father through the Son. … the distinction drawn between Son and Spirit also serves to insist upon their unity.”[9] This last point is more about Nicaea than the Apostles’ Creed.

    [1] W. Reginald Ward and Richard P. Heitzenrater, eds. The Works of John Wesley: Journals and Diaries, vols. 18-24 (Nashville: Abingdon, 1988-2003), 18:249-50. See also Mark K. Olson, Wesley and Aldersgate: Interpreting Conversion Narratives (Routledge, 2019), and “Wesley’s Warmed Heart at Aldersgate — What Really Happen?” (https://wesleyscholar.com/wesleys-warmed-heart-at-aldersgate-what-really-happened/ accessed April 23, 2025); Kevin M. Watson, “Experience in the so-called ‘Wesleyan Quadrilateral’” at https://kevinmwatson.com/2013/05/13/experience-in-the-so-called-wesleyan-quadrilateral/#:~:text=Outler’s%20understanding%20of%20the%20role%20of%20experience%20in%20Wesley’s%20theology,of%20the%20current%20popular%20culture accessed April 23, 2025.

    [2] Tradition, not in a modern sense, but Christian antiquity. The Quadrilateral also did not function equilaterally, but in keeping with the sensibilities of the Protestant adherence to the primacy of Scripture. “Reason” is applied as a way for rational persons to mediate disagreement and evaluate doctrine and practice. See Ted A. Campbell, The “Wesleyan Quadrilateral,” 92–94.

    [3] Hart, Confessing and Believing, 147.

    [4] Walter R. Bouman, “I Believe in the Holy Spirit,” 200, in Van Harn, Exploring & Proclaiming the Apostles’ Creed.

    [5] Myers, The Apostles’ Creed, 44.

    [6] Hart, Confessing and Believing, 183.

    [7] Hart, Confessing and Believing, 184.

    [8] Harned, Creed and Personal Identity, 86.

    [9] Harned, Creed and Personal Identity, 86–87.

  • Apostles’ Creed (part 5)

    He ascended into heaven and sits at the right hand of God the Father Almighty. // And he will come to judge the living and the dead.

      • Ascended: “…Christians proclaimed a gospel of Christ’s bodily incarnation, bodily suffering, bodily death, bodily resurrection, and bodily ascension. The faith of the ancient church was not about spiritual escapes but fulness, including the life of the body. As Irenaeus said it in the second century, the Son of God ‘did not reject human nature or exalt himself above it,’ but united himself with our nature in order to unite us to God.”[1]
        • Matt. 28:18ff— “I’ll be with you always …” Luke 24:52–54 “[W]orshipped him…; and they were continually in the temple blessing God.” “Jesus was understood not to be absent from them but, even though no longer present with them in flesh and blodd … to be now nonetheless personally present to them and with them and in them in precisely the way that God was and is.”[2]
        • And the dramatic scene in John 20:17–23.
    • Resurrection → 40 days → Ascension → 10 days → Pentecost. And in all these passages (again in Acts 1), the disposition of the disciples is changed. They are no longer confused or in disbelief. All the pieces now fit together. And it is this ascended Jesus that the disciples experienced the abiding presence that was promised never to leave them.
    • The right hand of God …
      • Purification: Heb. 1:1–4; 8:1–2; 10:12; 12:2; Ps. 110:2. Jesus’ priestly role of providing purification of sins is completed.
      • Mediation: Heb. 2:14ff & 4:14ff. How should we see Jesus? Jesus has greater promises, covenant, and priesthood. (See also Heb 6:19–20). Jesus, sitting on the right of God, intercedes for us in Rom. 8:34.
      • Jesus sitting at God’s right hand brings forth all the OT imagery of God sitting on the throne and all things are underneath his authority. All powers and gods and kingdoms are God’s footstool. See Eph 1:20–22 and Col. 1:18b-20.
      • And Jesus will destroy every enemy under his feet (1 Cor 15:24–28; Ps. 8:6; 110:1).
      • All others stand in God’s presence. “Sits at the right hand of God” is unique and expresses divinity in every way. And the creed repeats “Father Almighty.”
      • So, the one who descended is the one who ascended. Once incarnated, God taking on flesh remains as Jesus ascends. God taking the form of a human is now permanent. “His risen hands still bore the scars of crucifixion, and with that scar tissue the whole story of Jesus’s particular life and ministry is carried forward into God’s identity and God’s future in a defining way, rather than being discarded or left behind as though it were merely an external shell, a husk bearing the seed of an essentially Christless mysticism or generic human religiosity. On the contrary, it is the particular things that Jesus did and said, and suffered—the ‘person’ we meet in the telling of the stories about these things—that are the very touchstone of Christian faith, for it is in and through and not apart from them that God’s character is divulged, and redemption is precisely and only a matter of our being conformed to Jesus’s own human likeness.”[3]
    • Judgment
      • “Make a joyful noise to the Lord, all the earth; break forth into joyous song and sing praises. Let the sea roar, and all that fills it; the world and those who live in it. Let the floods clap their hands; let the hills sing together for joy at the presence of the Lord, for he is coming to judge the earth. He will judge the world with righteousness, and the peoples with equity” Psalms 98:4, 7-9. NRSV
      • “This, it tells us, is how the story will end, and not in some other way… at a time appointed by God and in an ending that is no mere ending but itself a new beginning, a transformation of the cosmos rather than its gradual return to chaos and nothingness. … Yahweh, would finally step in to come and dwell among his people, bringing heaven and earth together and putting the earth right in order to make it fit for that indwelling.”[4]
      • The final scene of the drama of God. “It is part of the good news of the gospel. It is a joy to know that someone understands all the complexities and ambiguities of our lives. It is a joy to know that this one—the only one who is truly competent to judge—is ‘full of grace and truth’ (John 1:14). He comes to save, not to destroy, and he saves us by his judgment.”[5]
        • 2 Cor 5:10 in the context of being confident that ministry will judge by what is eternal and not according to the flesh.
        • Phil. 3:20–21. For our transformation.
        • Col. 3:1, 4.
      • “God’s judgments aim to create and restore justice and peace among the people of God and throughout the creation. In this sense, God’s activity as judge and savior is inseparable.”[6]
        • Judgment and salvation are closely linked. Ps. 51:2, 7, 10; 10:18; 68:5; 72:4; 98:8–9. Rom. 8:1.
        • Peter also preaches that Christ is the one ordained by God as judge of the living and the dead (Acts 10:42; 1 Pet. 4:5; cf. 2 Tim. 4:21). He calls his readers to holy living so that their deeds may glorify God ‘when he comes to judge’ (1 Pet. 2:12).”[7]
        • 1 Cor. 16:21–22 Maranatha! “Our Lord Come.”

    Final stanza of “Love Divine, All Loves Excelling.”

     Finish then thy new creation; pure and spotless let us be; Let us see thy great salvation perfectly restored in thee: Changed from glory into glory, till in heaven we take our place, Till we cast our crowns before thee, lost in wonder, love, and praise.

    [1] Myers, The Apostles’ Creed, 88.

    [2] Hart, Confessing and Believing, 148.

    [3] Hart, Confessing and Believing, 147.

    [4] Hart, Confessing and Believing, 159.

    [5] Myers, The Apostles’ Creed, 93.

    [6] Daniel L. Migliore, “From There He Will Come to Judge the Living and the Dead,” 179, in Van Harn, Exploring & Proclaiming the Apostles’ Creed.

    [7] Daniel L. Migliore, “From There He Will Come to Judge the Living and the Dead,” 181, in Van Harn, Exploring & Proclaiming the Apostles’ Creed.

  • Apostles’ Creed (part 4)

    Suffered under Pontius Pilate; // Was crucified, died and was buried. // He descended into hell. The third day he rose again from the dead.

      • Suffered— “Still, it’s not quite true that the creed just ignores everything that happens between Jesus’ birth and death. In fact, already among the earliest Christians it had become customary to sum up Jesus’ whole life under one word: ‘suffering.’ (Luke 24:26). Luke records that Paul summed up Jesus’ life in the same way: ‘It was necessary for the Messiah to suffer’ (Acts 17:3). By the time of the later New Testament writings, the word ‘suffering’ has become a convenient formula for referring to the whole story of Jesus’ life and death: ‘he suffered’ (Heb 2:18).”[1]
        • And 1 Pet 4:1. And in our baptism, we share in his sufferings, Rom 8:17.
        • And our identification with Jesus’ suffering is connected to Jesus: death, descended, resurrected, and ascended…
    • “From a different angle, the insistence that Christ—and in him, God—suffered is important because it tells us that God is not remote from or unacquainted with the sorts of suffering, often dreadful suffering, that [we] experience in life. The scale of suffering in God’s world is one of the biggest problems for believers and unbelievers alike when it comes to making sense of the world and of the claim that God is its creator and sustainer. … [God experiences] ‘godforsaken’ in order to sustain us through it and to break its hold over us. This is a God who is never closer to us, that is to say, than he is in the midst of our seeming ‘godforsakennes,’ and such suffering has no power to isolate or to distance us from God. He has been there before us, and he goes there with us.”[2]
      • Compare:
        • 22:2–3, 22 “My God, my God, why have You abandoned me—  far from my deliverance, the words of my howling?!  3 My God! I call out by day, and You do not answer— and by night, but there is no rest for me. “22 Deliver me from the lion’s mouth, and from the horns of wild oxen… You have answered me!”
        • “When he had received the drink, Jesus said, ‘It is finished.’ With that, he bowed his head and gave up his spirit” John 19:30.
      • The narratival substructure of Paul’s writings is the death, burial, and resurrection of Jesus.
        • Jesus’ death was not expected.[3] The crucifixion meant that the Kingdom did not come, and Jesus was not the Messiah.
        • Jesus’ death is connected deeply with our atonement. Jesus died for us. Many images … none alone carry the fullness of meaning or literal explanation. Taken together is the best we can do to get our minds around how God addresses sin. Each of the images has a point of comparison but also limitations.[4]
          • Religious sacrifice at the Temple.
          • Justice-to satisfy a penalty.
          • Winning the cosmic battle between good and evil. Christus Victor.
          • Paying a debt or paying a price for human sin.
          • The redemption price someone pays to free a slave. Liberated from bondage.
          • Born from above or rebirth.
          • New Creation.
      • 1 Peter 2:20–25. It is more than Jesus substituting himself for us, but he set an example “to enable us to suffer and die as we follow in his footsteps. Indeed, we might say that part of what sets him apart from us and makes his suffering and death unique is their capacity, as the suffering and death of God, to be generative of ours as we are united ever more fully to him by the Holy Spirit. As we grow more like him, so we too begin to ‘suffer’ sin in the world and in ourselves … coming to see things as God sees them, to feel things as God feels them, our moral and spiritual lives being reorientated until our familiar bearings no longer grant us any stability or guidance. As the Spirit infuses us with the life and the ‘power’ of Christ’s obedience, we too will increasingly find ourselves at odds with the world and its values, and participation in its shared institutions and practices will begin to chafe at points like an ill-fitting shoe until we are raw.”[5]
    • He descended … A way of saying that Jesus shares in the fullness of death. “Our Lord’s destiny also includes his conception, birth, suffering, crucifixion, death, and burial. After declaring ‘He descended into hell,’ the Creed further recounts his resurrection, ascension, session, and promised coming to judge the living and the dead. Hell therefore could be taken as one of the discrete scenes in the drama of redemption.”[6]
      • How do we dare to look at the cross or hear the story again? What happened in the life of God between Good Friday and Easter Sunday? That is more than a pause but requires us to deeply reflect. Therefore, rejoice when Jesus says, “It is finished.” Only then can we look.[7]
      • Interpretive Possibilities:
        • It could characterize what befell Jesus Christ in his crucifixion.
        • It could portray more deeply the victory over sin and death wrought by his resurrection.[8]
        • 6 referencing Sheol (a place of the dead who await the coming Day of the Lord). See also Ps 139; 16:10; 22:15; 30:3, 9; 69:2. Or, referencing the grave as you await the coming day of the Lord.
        • Sheol as the place of the dead or Hades. Ps. 88; Acts 2:27, 31.
        • Kay, quoting Rufinus (ca. 404), A Commentary on the Apostles’ Creed, “In order to accomplish salvation through the weakness of flesh that His divine nature went down to death in the flesh. The intention was not that He might be held fast by death according to the law governing mortals, but that, assured of rising again by His own power, He might open the gates of death. It was as if a king were to go to a dungeon and, entering it, were to fling open its doors, loosen the fetters break the chains, bolts, and bars in pieces, conduct the captives forth to freedom, and restore such as sat in darkness and in the shadow of death [cf. Ps. 107:10] to light and life. In a case like this the king is, of course, said to have been in the dungeon, but not under the same circumstances as the prisoners confined within it. They were there to discharge their penalties, but he to secure their discharge from punishment.”[9]
          • Death is not God. Death does not have the final word. “For to this end Christ died and lived again, so that he might be Lord of both the dead and the living” (Rom. 14:9).
          • Jesus follows humanity’s descent into death so that humanity may then follow Jesus in rising up to freedom. Jesus is not a victim of death; he is the victor over death.[10]
          • Descended into Hell is the first act of resurrection.
        • Gehenna—the place of fire, eternal punishment taken from the Valley of Hinnom, a ravine south of Jerusalem (2 Chron 28:3; 33:6; Jer. 7:31; 32:35; see Jer. 7:30–34; 19). See also Matt. 25:41.
        • The tension between Sheol (the place of the dead) and Gehenna (a place of eternal punishment).
          • Symbolic interpretation. Not a historical referent in the story, but a referent to the suffering of death on the cross for the redemption of humanity.
          • Kay, referencing Calvin’s interpretation says, “Christ died in the place of sinners (Isa. 53:4–6). As such, he suffered in body and soul the torments of damnation, of God’s severity, wrath, and judgment. ‘No wonder, then, if he is said to have descended into hell, for he suffered the death that God in his wrath had inflicted upon the wicked!’ In this sense, the imagery of Gehenna replaces that of Sheol as more adequate in describing the depths of anguish that the Son of God endured for the sake of sinners.”[11] Therefore, Ps. 22:1. Hell is godforsakenness. Jesus’ dying was not routine death but the death of the ages where sin’s full curse was met. Only “Hell” describes it.
        • Yet, as Jesus approached death, Jesus still cried out to God. Descended into Hell is where death and resurrection meet. It is here, not so much sequential but theological, that sin and redemption meet and victory over sin is won. “He died for All” (2 Cor. 5).
        • The descent into Hell is the place where death, sinners, and Hell hear the Gospel and encounter the Savior, 1 Pet 3:19–20. “According to Dante, the gates of hell have an inscription above them that reads: ‘Abandon all hope, ye who enter here.’”[12] The Gospel is preached when there is godforsakenness, where there is no hope, and when God seems most silent. Even when Christ is dead and buried, the preaching of the gospel goes on.[13]
    • So, asking again, how do we dare to look at the cross or hear the story again? What happened in the life of God between Good Friday and Easter Sunday? That is more than a pause but requires us to deeply reflect. Therefore, rejoice when Jesus says, “It is finished.” Only then can we look.[14]
      • Parable of Luke 16:19–31. He descended, breaking the logic of Jesus’ own parable by crossing and demonstrating his power over death and being the embodiment of good news.
      • Compare the images of Picasso’s Guernica covered up at the UN, January 27 as described by Johnston.[15]  Do images of Hell call on us to preach the truth of the Gospel?
      • See also John 11:23–27; Matt 16:18; Eph 4:8–10; Rev 1:17–18.
    • Resurrection
      • If the disciples did not expect crucifixion, they certainly did not expect resurrection. [16] Not only in the resurrection predictions (e.g., Mk 8:31) but as already seen in John 20. Resurrection is a day of astonishment.
      • “The resurrection, wrote Barth, ‘involves a definite seeing with the eyes and hearing with the ears and handling with the hands, as the Easter stories say so unmistakably and emphatically. … It involves real eating and drinking, speaking and answering, reasoning … and doubting and then, believing’ (IV/2, p. 143).”[17] Resurrection is as concrete as his death.
      • Therefore, as the risen one, Jesus is transcendent, eternal, and present. The Living Christ is a Real Presence.
      • He was resurrected. You cannot have crucifixion without resurrection and resurrection without crucifixion.
        • Cross shaped life
        • Resurrection shaped life
      • Along with the incarnation, the resurrection of the body (soma) exhorts us to take the creative material world seriously.
      • I believe, “He is risen!” Except when it is embarrassing or inconvenient to believe so. Except when completing my taxes, casting my vote, making investments, receiving the immigrant, loving my enemies, respecting all peoples, or other morally compromising positions. What is a resurrection-shaped life?
      • Resurrected body—not corrupt but material and spiritual. His resurrected hands still bore the scars of crucifixion. Jesus’ bones are not still with us in a grave. (See 1 Cor. 15, Phil. 3:21 and 1 John 3:2).
      • “The nature of the resurrected body, according to Christian theology, is described as transformed, imperishable, and glorified. The most detailed description comes from 1 Corinthians 15:35-58, where the Apostle Paul contrasts our current physical bodies with the spiritual, resurrected body. Here are some key aspects:
        • Imperishable & Immortal – Unlike our current bodies, which age, decay, and die, the resurrected body will be incorruptible and will never perish (1 Corinthians 15:42, 53-54).
        • Glorified – It will be raised in glory, meaning it will be radiant and perfected, free from the weaknesses and flaws of earthly bodies (1 Corinthians 15:43; Philippians 3:21).
        • Powerful – The resurrected body will be filled with power, no longer subject to frailty, sickness, or suffering (1 Corinthians 15:43).
        • Spiritual, yet Physical – Paul contrasts the “natural body” with a “spiritual body” (1 Corinthians 15:44). This doesn’t mean it will be non-physical, but that it will be fully empowered by the Spirit of God, like Jesus’ resurrected body.
        • Like Christ’s Resurrected Body – Philippians 3:21 says that believers’ bodies will be transformed to be like Christ’s resurrected body. After His resurrection, Jesus could be touched (Luke 24:39), eat food (Luke 24:42-43), and yet also appear and disappear at will (Luke 24:31, John 20:19).
        • Perfectly Suited for Eternal Life – The resurrected body is made for the new heavens and new earth, where there is no death, pain, or sorrow (Revelation 21:4).”[18]

     

    [1] Myers, The Apostles’ Creed, 58.

    [2] Hart, Confessing and Believing, 105.

    [3] John 20:1–18.

    [4] See Hart, Confessing and Believing, 110–11, for significance and limitations of atonement imagery.

    [5] Hart, Confessing and Believing, 123.

    [6] James F. Kay, “He Descended into Hell,” 118, in Van Harn, Exploring & Proclaiming the Apostles’ Creed.

    [7] Scott Black Johnston, “Harrowing,” 131, in Van Harn, Exploring & Proclaiming the Apostles’ Creed.

    [8] James F. Kay, “He Descended into Hell,” 118, in Van Harn, Exploring & Proclaiming the Apostles’ Creed.

    [9] James F. Kay, “He Descended into Hell,” 120–21, in Van Harn, Exploring & Proclaiming the Apostles’ Creed.

    [10] James F. Kay, “He Descended into Hell,” 121, in Van Harn, Exploring & Proclaiming the Apostles’ Creed.

    [11] James F. Kay, “He Descended into Hell,” 125, in Van Harn, Exploring & Proclaiming the Apostles’ Creed.

    [12] Scott Black Johnston, “Harrowing,” 135, in Van Harn, Exploring & Proclaiming the Apostles’ Creed.

    [13] Scott Black Johnston, “Harrowing,” 135, in Van Harn, Exploring & Proclaiming the Apostles’ Creed.

    [14] Scott Black Johnston, “Harrowing,” 131, in Van Harn, Exploring & Proclaiming the Apostles’ Creed.

    [15] Scott Black Johnston, “Harrowing,” 132, 135, in Van Harn, Exploring & Proclaiming the Apostles’ Creed.

    [16] N. T. Wright, Surprised by Hope, (London: SPCK, 2007), 51.

    [17] George Hunsinger, “On the Third Day He Arose Again from the Dead,” 151, in Van Harn, Exploring & Proclaiming the Apostles’ Creed.

    [18] OpenAI. 2025. ChatGPT (AI Language Model). Accessed February 21, 2025. https://openai.com

  • Apostles’ Creed (part 3)

    And in Jesus Christ, God’s only Son, our Lord. // Who was conceived by the Holy Ghost, // Born of the Virgin Mary.

      • Eccl 11:1–11. Is there anything new under the sun? Is there anything where we might say, “Look! This is new?” God in the flesh.
      • “And” I believe in Jesus Christ …
        • God the Father and Jesus the Son are not one and the same but forever distinct from one another. The unity is not a fusion/blending.
        • Yet, God the Father and Jesus the Son are not independent of one another. “God is eternally the Father of the Son, and the Crucified is eternally the Son of the Father. They can never be separated; when they are not acknowledged together, neither is worshiped or glorified at all.”[1]
      • The Father sends the obedient Son and the Son freely goes by his own initiative. And in so doing reveals God, not someone different, but someone more fully revealed.
        • But not completely. For example, God’s holiness is not a theme developed in speaking of Jesus. Illustration: “On a visit to the theater, we are all familiar with the way in which, in any drama, things known about a key character in acts 1 and 2 can be transfigured by things that only come to light in act 3. The change in our perception may be and often is radical and once we have experienced it, we can never back and see acts 1 and 2 in the same way again.”[2] And if you stumble into the play at act 3, with no prior knowledge of the play, “We would almost certainly become one of those annoying people who whisper their questions (loudly) to the person sitting next to them through the remainder of the performance. … [We are] “uninformed and malformed if we do not know our Old Testament well.”[3]
    • Jesus Christ
      • A story, a name, a title. Jesus—everything is centered in a particular time and place. And Jesus is given titles: “Christ”, “only Son,” “our Lord.”
      • The Christ Event: 2 Tim 2:8 “Remember Jesus Christ …”
        • The Master Story of Phil 2:6–11. “Because he was in the form of God, he humbled himself.”
        • “[Jesus] is Emmanuel, God in the highest, God with us and for us, God become like us and one of us, but without sin.”[4]
        • Rich avenues of exploration include the “I Am” statements in John that are rooted in God’s name YHWH.  “Lord” as it connects to “Adonai” “YHWH” and “Kyrios.”
        • Jesus as prophet, priest, and king. Lord. “I Am.” And various titles. Especially here, “Christ” — Messiah, the anointed one. See Acts 2:36 and Col 1:18ff.
        • Atonement—Exchange Formula. See 2 Cor 5:21, 8:9; Heb 9:13–14.
      • God alone is the creator of all things (John 1 & Heb 1).
      • God alone has authority over all things (Phil 2).
      • God alone is worshiped (Matt 28).
      • Therefore, “all deity (Col 2:9).
    • The Nicene Creed’s purpose was to expound upon the nature of the Son due to contextual controversies.
    • What is the Holy Spirit’s role in the story of God?
      • Gen 1:1–2 The Spirit hovers over creation.
      • Ps 104:30 “When you send forth our spirit, they are created.”
      • Gen 2:7 God breathes spirit into the clay, and it becomes a living being.
      • Isa. 32:15 God’s Spirit is poured out over all flesh connected to the restoration of Israel. See also Isa 11:2; 51:11; 61:1; 63:10–11; and Joel 2:28). The Holy Spirit brings about restoration and connected to the holiness of God and the holiness required of God’s people.
      • “So when the Spirit broods over the womb of Mary, we see a picture of God’s creative work happening all over again.”[5]
      • Referencing Origin’s imagery of an iron rod placed in fire, Ben Myers states, “Jesus is truly human: nothing but iron. He is truly divine: nothing but fire. Jesus is so permeated by the divine presence that every part of his humanity is filled with divine energy. He is born of a woman: he is conceived by God’s Spirit. He is human: he is divine. He is iron: he is fire.”[6]
      • And the story continues with Elizabeth (Lk 1:41). And in us Rom 8:11. And it is the same Spirit (Acts 1:12; 2:1–4) where we find the conception of the Church.
    • Virgin Mary
      • The Creed is not designed to answer questions about biology but to give witness to a mystery. (See Matt. 1:20, Lk. 1:35).
      • How many turning point stories can you name that hinged on the birth of a child? The child carried the very promise of God. Especially women who, it is miraculous that they conceived.
        • Sara
        • Rachel
        • Samson’s mother (Judg. 13)
        • Hannah
        • Elizabeth
        • Mary
        • Isa 54:1–3, 13
      • Paternity—our paternity is like his paternity
        • Born of God (John 1:11–12).
        • Born from above (John 3).
        • Rom. 1:3–4 “concerning [God’s] Son, who was descended from David according to the flesh and designated Son of God in power according to the Spirit of holiness and by his resurrection from the dead, Jesus Christ our Lord.”

    [1] Harned, Creed and Personal Identity, 49. See Appendix A.

    [2] Hart, Confessing and Believing, 71.

    [3] Hart, Confessing and Believing, 71.

    [4] Harned, Creed and Personal Identity, 51.

    [5] Myers, The Apostles’ Creed, 44.

    [6] Myers, The Apostles’ Creed, 44–45.

  • Apostles’ Creed (part 2)

    I believe // In God the Father, // Almighty, Maker of heaven and earth.

      • Gen 1:1 “In the beginning God …” The Bible assumes God.
      • Not so much “what” we believe in but “whom” we believe in.
      • Rom 11 doxology. What does the term God mean? “After all, God, in biblical and Christian terms, refers us to a reality lying way beyond the natural range and reach of anything of which our bodies, minds, and languages together are properly adapted to know and speak. … speak of God … as the uncreated source of ‘all things, visible and invisible.’” [1]
        • Via negativia.
        • God does reveal God’s Self in creation, Scripture, and most fully in Jesus.
      • Ex. 3—God self-revelation. Both identity/character and actions – God’s story.
      • See also Ex. 34:6–7. God the Father. Monotheism is rooted in the first command. The first violation of the covenant was Ex 32 with the golden calf. Ex 34 is a midrash on the first commandment. God’s self-revelation. God as creator, almighty, none other. God is not just the center, but all in all, all-inclusive. Therefore, exclusive devotion. The Nicene Creed goes further adding terminology from Col 1:16, “all things, visible and invisible.” This spotlights the nonmaterial, the spiritual realities. [2]
      • And it is more than acknowledgment, but I put my faith in God, I trust God. I believe in God. The Shema, “Hear, O Israel: The Lord is our God, the Lord alone. You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your might” (Deut. 6:4–5).
      • And according to the Creed, “I believe in one God, the Father…and in one Lord Jesus Christ, … and I believe in the Holy Spirit.”
      • God is …
        • Love (1 Jn. 4:8).
        • Light (1 Jn. 1:5).
        • Spirit (Jn. 4:26).
        • Holy (Lev. 19:1).
        • Faithful (1 Cor. 1:18).
        • Good (Lk. 18:19).
        • Able (2 Cor. 9:8).
    • Why Did God create the heavens and the earth?
      • God’s Glory.
      • Out of God’s Love. “God, in love, eternally purposed a creation marked by order rather than chaos and so fit for human habitation and flourishing together with God and with our fellow creatures.”[3] To understand an obligation to this cosmic order and be a summons to worship this same God.
      • And God will bring to completion the “goodness” of God’s creative intent.
    • God as Father is a relational metaphor.
      • 1 Cor 8:6 “I believe in one God the Father …” as the ultimate ground of the cosmos, the one “from whom are all things,” the one who generates all things. [4]
      • Seen in the Lord’s Prayer–Our Father.
        • New birth. Gal 4 with our adoption into God’s family. Not by creation but by adoption.\
        • Eucharist as family meal.
        • Familial language. Household language. The church is the household of God.
        • God’s deep and abiding concern for widows and orphans who are excluded from family.
    • What is the OT conception of God as Father?[5]
      • The OT uses the term “father” 15 times (Israel referred to as “son” or “child of God” 9 more times.[6]
      • Jesus calls God “my Father and your Father” (Jn 20:17), “Your heavenly Father (Mt 6:14), Jesus teaches his disciples to pray, “Our Father” (Mt 6:9). Jesus uses the term “father” 160 times. He does not use the term “Lord” to refer to God (the OT’s favorite term). [7] There is something unique in Jesus’ relationship with the Father. Jesus is the begotten Son, the one and only Son. The relationship is defined particularly.
        • “C. S. Lewis observed, that one ‘begets’ something fundamentally like oneself (and similarly for what proceeds from oneself), while one ‘creates’ or ‘makes’ something unlike oneself.”[8]
        • Tertullian, “Father makes a son to be a father, and a son must have a father to be a son.”
          • When did I become a father?
          • When did God become “Our Father”? So the unique relationship that Jesus has with the Father is now available to us.
    • Is there a problem with the word “father” today? The early church also saw this issue and did not use the term in gendered ways but used it to connote relationships.
      • K. Cukrowski’s list of feminine expressions of God in the Bible.[9]
    • “Almighty” — How is “power” understood theologically?
      • “Almighty” is associated with and modified by the fact that the Almighty is Father and Creator. It makes a difference who has the power.
      • Isa 45: 6–7.
    • There is that which God cannot do. God cannot die. God cannot lie. God cannot do unjustly.[10]
    • More like maternal love caring for an infant, a power found in weakness, a cruciformed power seen at the cross. Kenosis is who God is and not an attribute God puts on when needed.
    • “When the accent falls upon the first word of this confession, God, is our Father, persons find reason to cherish themselves even when all the reasons the world could offer have vanished. Because God is their Father, they are worthy to exist and worthy in existence; no worldly evidence against them can contradict the significance of this paternity.”[11]

    [1] Hart, Confessing and Believing, 17.

    [2] Hart, Confessing and Believing, 51.

    [3] Hart, Confessing and Believing, xv.

    [4] Richard A. Norris, “I Believe in God, the Father Almighty,” 24, in Van Harn, Exploring & Proclaiming the Apostles’ Creed.

    [5] Keyways the Old Testament portrays God as Father:

    • Creator and Provider: God is described as the Creator of humanity, which can be seen as a paternal relationship. For example, in Deuteronomy 32:6, God is referred to as the one who “made you and established you” and in Isaiah 64:8, God is acknowledged as the “Father” who shapes and forms Israel. God’s care for creation and humanity is likened to a father’s nurturing role.
    • Father of the Nation of Israel: The concept of God as the Father of Israel is more prominent. In Exodus 4:22-23, God refers to Israel as His “firstborn son,” and He commands Pharaoh to let Israel go free. Similarly, in Deuteronomy 14:1, Israel is called “children of the Lord your God,” emphasizing a special relationship between God and the nation. Isaiah 63:16 also refers to God as the “Father” of Israel, noting that He is the “Redeemer” and protector of His people.
    • Fatherly Discipline and Care: God’s fatherhood is sometimes associated with discipline and instruction. In Proverbs 3:11-12, the Lord’s discipline is likened to a father’s loving correction: “The Lord disciplines those he loves, as a father the son he delights in.” Hosea 11:1-4 portrays God as a loving father who raised Israel but also expresses sorrow over Israel’s rebellion. This passage shows both the care and grief a father might feel for a wayward child.
    • Father of the King: In certain royal psalms, such as Psalm 2:7 and Psalm 89:26-27, God is depicted as the Father of the king, particularly the Davidic king. This represents a special relationship between God and the monarch, who is seen as God’s son in a more symbolic and representative sense.
    • Limitations of the Old Testament View: While the Old Testament includes references to God as a father, the understanding is often more about God’s role as Creator, protector, and disciplinarian, and it is more collective in nature (focused on Israel) rather than the individualized, intimate fatherhood seen in later Christian theology.

    [6] Hart, Confessing and Believing, 41.

    [7] Hart, Confessing and Believing, 41.

    [8] Marguerite Shuster, “The Triune God,” 6, in Van Harn, Exploring & Proclaiming the Apostles’ Creed.

    [9] See Appendix B. Ken Cukrowski, Class Notes. Shared by request as an email attachment.

    [10] Augustine, De symbol ad catechumenos 2. Quoted in Richard A. Norris, “I Believe in God, the Father Almighty,” 31, in Van Harn, Exploring & Proclaiming the Apostles’ Creed.

    [11] Harned, Creed and Personal Identity, 33.

  • Apostles’ Creed

    On February 16th, I began a new Sunday morning Bible class series on the Apostles’ Creed. Over the next eleven weeks, I will post my notes.

    The earliest known story about the origin of the Apostles’ Creed says, “As they were on the point of taking leave of each other, they first settled an agreed norm for their future preaching, so that they might not find themselves, widely separated as they would be, giving out different doctrines to the people they invited to believe in Christ. So they met together in one spot and, being filled with the Holy Spirit, compiled this brief token of their future preaching, each making the contribution he thought fit; and they decreed that it should be handed out as standard teaching to believers.” 5th century, Rufinus of Aquileia.[1]

    There are possible remnants of creeds and hymns in the Bible. Let us give careful attention to the actual substance of “the faith that was once for all entrusted to the saints” Jude 1:3. For example, “He was revealed in flesh, vindicated in spirit, seen by angels, proclaimed among Gentiles, believed in throughout the world, taken up in glory” (1 Tim 3:16; and other hymns in the Pastorals; hallmark texts are found throughout the NT e.g., Phil. 2:6–11.). See also 1 Cor. 15:1–3 concise statement of the Gospel.

    Credo: “is derived from cor, heart, and do, dare, to give; its meaning was to swear loyalty or pledge allegiance.[2]

    Creeds developed usually out of a certain context. Not so with the Apostle’s Creed which is more of a narrative statement of belief. The common understanding of its origin connects it with baptism.

    Is what follows a reasonable and coherent outlook on reality? The “internal coherence” of the world of Christian beliefs and practices and the “external coherence” to the wider set of beliefs we and our fellow citizens share. And then the implications of these beliefs are what?[3]

    1. In America, what are the pledges we make?
      • “In God we trust.”
      • Pledge of Allegiance
      • Pledges of marriage
    2. Hippolytus, Apostolic Tradition, notes how a person is asked three questions about God, Son, and Holy Spirit. The response is, “I believe.” (Three-fold baptism).  A credo was given at the beginning of my journey. “God promises to be faithful even when children of God are faithless.”[4]
    3. In Churches of Christ, what were you asked to confess at your baptism?
      • Jesus is the Son of God
      • Jesus is Lord
      • Or more often simply “yes”.

    I believe

      • “I” while personal is confessed in community.
        • In the earliest tradition, “I” is a confession made at baptism. No one is invited to come up with their own personal statement of belief. All are invited to be immersed into a reality beyond themselves and to join their individual voices to a communal voice that transcends them all.
        • “I, but not I, but Christ in me.” Who am I to make such a confession. It is a gift, this faith I have. My identity can no longer be described apart from Jesus Christ. “I no longer live, but Christ lives in me.”
        • Eph 1:3–14 as a gift bestowed by the Benefactor.
        • At baptism, I am given a new identity, a new name: ‘Child of God.’ I am baptized in the name of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit.

    “Believe” —

      • Intellectual assent (Newman’s “notional assent”) and enacted faith (Newman’s “real assent”) are related but quite different.[5] “Real assent” is an engaged, committed, trusting disposition of the whole person. Our profession when we say the Apostles’ Creed is enacted faith. Enacted faith on the part of God’s people, is a response to God’s presence, by participating in God’s blessing of the world.[6]
      • “I believe” is both informative and performative. When combined with baptism, it is sacramental. “I believe” is a pledge, promise, commitment, a confession. The credo is a promise more than a set of systematic statements of belief.
        • Informative in that it provides the basic substance of the faith. “I believe in…” And here is a list of what we believe in. It then functions as a mnemonic device for our own faith and our witness to others.
        • Performative in that it does something. (Marriage, Blessing, “I sentence you.” “You’re Fired”).
          • “I believe that …” Good, even the demons believe.
          • “I believe in …” forms us and shapes us.
          • And as a symbol in front of others. It is said in community. We do not perjure ourselves. And we will not recant.
        • Rom 10:9: “If you confess with your lips that Jesus is Lord and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved.”
      • Systematics: Consider what is missing in the creed. Not just elements of God’s story (Abraham, Moses/Law, David, life of Jesus, discipleship, prayer, love) but also key doctrines (e.g., covenant).
      • So not a loyalty oath to a set of beliefs but to the triune God. The credo is a master image for me to see.[7]
      • Such belief orients me to how I see myself, how I see you, how I see the economy, politics, recreation, vocation, family, (etc.), and how I see the world. Such belief frames my worldview, my reality, my frame of reference. I commit myself to this story and not some other philosophy or story. Even God’s story narrows in how you will see the world as shown in Hebrews 1. God spoke in various times, ways, and persons. But now God speaks through God’s Son.

    AND “I believe” is an acknowledgment of the faithfulness of God.[8] For even when I am faithless, I believe in God the Father, I believe in the Son, and I believe in the Holy Spirit.

    [1] Geoffrey Wainwright, “Forward,” ix, in Van Harn, Exploring & Proclaiming the Apostles’ Creed.

    [2] Harned, Creed and Personal Identity, 16.

    [3] Hart, Confessing and Believing, xiv.

    [4] Harned, Creed and Personal Identity, 19.

    [5] John Henry Newman, An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of Assent (London: Burns, Oates, & Co., 1870).

    [6] What is “enacted faith”? It begins with Peirce’s connection between “belief” and “habit” rooted in Alexander Bain’s definition of belief, “that upon which a [person] is prepared to act.” See Bain, The Emotions and the Will, 505. Dallas Willard, Renovation of the Heart: Putting on the Character of Christ (Colorado Springs: NAV, 2002), xxx similarly states, “Belief is when your whole being is set to act as if something is so.”

    [7] Harned, Creed and Personal Identity, 23.

    [8] Harned, Creed and Personal Identity, 24.

  • Taking Our Stand

    Ephesians 6:10ff

    And Paul says “Finally” —the bottom line; the point of decision; bringing it all together; finally! Vv 11-12.

    How do you picture Satan?

      • Red suit; T-shirt “The Devil Made Me Do It;” Sitting on your shoulder; Halloween.
      • Terri Gibb’s song—”Somebody’s knocking, should I let him in. It may be the Devil; I don’t want to do wrong. I never thought he would have blue eyes and blue jeans.”
      • We need a police MO (Mode of Operation). 2 Cor. 2:11 “We are not unaware of his schemes.”
      • There is a battle going on. Our struggle, not my struggle, but our struggle, is not with flesh and blood. A battle that takes place in the heavenlies (a cosmic battle). A spiritual war that the apocalypse describes as a beast & a dragon that is attacking the church.

    But there is also a Lion & a Lamb in that battle.

      • Old Testament depiction of God as warrior, his armor and his host.
      • 42:13 The Lord will march out like a mighty man, like a warrior he will stir up his zeal; with a shout he will raise the battle cry and will triumph over his enemies.
      • 59:17 He put on righteousness as his breastplate, and the helmet of salvation on his head; he put on the garments of vengeance and wrapped himself in zeal as in a cloak.
      • 11:4-5 With righteousness he will judge the needy, with justice he will give decisions for the poor of the earth. He will strike the earth with the rod of his mouth; with the breath of his lips, he will stay the wicked. Righteousness will be his belt and faithfulness the sash around his waist.
      • 35:1-3 Contend, O Lord, with those who contend with me; fight against those who fight against me. Take up shield and buckler; arise and come to my aid. Brandish spear and javelin against those who pursue me. Say to my soul, “I am your salvation.”

    And we are here. And Paul is not unaware of the cosmic struggle the church faces. He recognizes that the battles of the heavenlies are being played in the “earthlies”, the “everydays” of our lives. The principalities and powers use the weapon of fear against us. You see this easily in American politics. What about the immigrant?  What about inflation? What about the environmental crisis? What about our health care? And the list is long. If you do not allign yourself with the powers we are selling, then your whole future, and the future of our nation is lost. Fear is a powerful weapon.

    Therefore, he prays.

      • Eph 1:19 –to comprehend. Seen in the resurrection and enthronement of Jesus. Seen in our own resurrection and enthronement. Seen in two peoples being one church 2:19ff.
      • Eph 3:14 –to apprehend.
      • Resurrection Power is available to us.
      • We usually think about the various pieces of armor individually. We ask, “What does it mean for you to wear a belt of truth?” etc. Communally, we should also ask, “What does it mean for us, the church, to wear a belt of truth?” etc.

    Conclusion:

      • So, Finally, be strong in the Lord and in his mighty power. Put on the full armor of God [compared to the clothing of Eph 4] … And Paul ends his admonition with exhortation to prayer.
      • Paul begins with an admonition to stand strong. When God marches with his host, angels bow before him, enemies are crushed beneath him, heaven and earth adore him, and we are rescued, we are equipped, and we are empowered, for we are his church—united we are called to arms. It is not just any armor or weapons that are at our disposal, but those of God himself. They are available to us who believe.

    Looking Back

    1. What have you learned and how have you been challenged from Ephesians about your identity?
    2. What have you learned from Paul in Ephesians about Christ’s body, the church? What does the church need to hear?
    3. Why do we need Ephesians?
  • The Other Six Days

    Ephesians 5:22–6:9

    In David deSilva’s Honor, Patronage, Kinship & Purity: Unlocking New Testament Culture, he says about Ephesians 5-6 (along with Colossians 3-4): “These are among the less popular passages in the New Testament epistles, mainly on account of the facility with which they are employed to affirm patterns of interfamilial relationship that degrade the female partner in favor of the male or children in favor the parent. … The authoritarian aspect of these texts can be very appealing for males. … Abuses of this kind have, however, no place in the Christian home, since these passages are but a small part of the larger enterprise of the great household code being formed throughout the New Testament teaching ‘how one ought to behave in the household of God, which is the church of the living God’ (1 Tim. 3:15). … Mutual love, unity, cooperation for one another’s good, putting the interests of the other ahead of one’s own – all these forms the relational context in which these household codes are to be enacted and the interpretive lens through which they are to be understood and applied.” (Quote comes from Highlands Teacher’s Notes).

      • In many ways, the American church does not resemble a household. Family is structured differently. Especially with so many homes not defined by two parents at home, much less grandparents.
      • Keep verse 32 in mind. The profound mystery is that households are just illustrations about Christ and the church. How is the church like a household? How has that been true for you?

    By Submitting to One Another (5:21).

      • Since there is no verb (in Greek) in verse 22, the verb is inferred from this final challenge to submit to one another. Likely the entire “household code” (5:22 – 6:9) flows out of that. These relationships are part of a much larger call to discipleship, mutuality, service, and submission.
      • And Paul uses the concrete situations of marriage, parenting, and vocation to challenge all of us to imitate God in all our relationships, living the life of love, just as Christ loved us and gave himself up for us as a fragrant offering and sacrifice to God.
      • Part of what separates Paul’s “code” from other “household codes” from the Greco-Roman world was the way he leaned into the mutuality. Those who had the power in that culture (husbands, fathers/parents, and masters) were all instructed to live out the gospel.
      • Choose any example from your everyday life: going fishing, teacher/parent conference, sell property, child’s birthday party, supper club, neighborhood parade/picnic, etc.
      • How will we love, forgive, encourage, benefit those who listen, … finding out what pleases the Lord and making the most of your opportunities to express your God likeness in the way you walk with people?

    In Review of whole section of exhortations in Ephesians 4:1–6:9

    As Paul develops the kind of life the gospel produces (in chapters 4-6), he keeps pointing to love, mutuality, and submission. “Be completely humble and gentle; be patient, bearing with one another in love” (4:2). If you see 4:2 and 5:21 as bookends (an inclusio) on God imitating virtues, then the whole section exhorting one another relations is characterized by humility and submission. The theme is woven throughout, for example “… for we are all members of one body” (4:25); “Be kind and compassionate to one another, forgiving each other, just as in Christ God forgave you” (4:32); “Walk in the way of love, just as Christ loved us and gave himself up for us as a fragrant offering and sacrifice to God” (5:2).

    Questions:

      • In what way does this life “fit” the story of Jesus? Who is an example of someone you know whose life fits this virtuous way of being?
      • Since Paul says (4:20f) that we have “learned the Messiah,” how does that help us flesh out kingdom living? Take note that by using “one another” three times in Eph. 4, Paul sets up the themes of mutuality and submission.
      • How do we cultivate these communal virtues? For example:
        • Spiritual Conversation (5:19a).
        • Spiritual Songs (5:19b).
        • Continual Thanksgiving (5:20).
        • Submitting to One Another (5:21).